StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Analysis of Plato's Views of Justice and Poetry - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An Analysis of Plato’s Views of Justice and Poetry The argument of Plato in The Republic that the issue of poetry’s nature takes place prior to any comprehensive investigation of justice is accomplished draws both appealing and not quite appealing conceptualization of justice…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Analysis of Platos Views of Justice and Poetry
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Plato's Views of Justice and Poetry"

Download file to see previous pages

However, given Plato’s perception of justice, this appears to be an implausible argument within the point of view of The Republic. Certainly, Plato’s further analysis of the poets in Book Ten is appealing and commonly believed to be his ultimate conclusion on the issue; however, Socrates’s argument, which is found in Book Three, makes the argument of Plato quite unappealing to readers, which are placed in a shaky position that invites one to regard justice and poetry together, specifically, as being interdependent.

Hence, this paper examines both these arguments. This paper attempts to demonstrate that the issues of justice and poetry, which are widely viewed to be independent themes in The Republic, are not merely interconnected essentially but vital to one another in the theoretical or philosophical mechanism of comprehending them. The connection between justice and poetry involves the following premises: as Plato rejects the legally oriented conceptualizations of justice, in which interactions and relations between citizens are characterized by definite approaches to acting, he likewise denounces an accurate, or legally oriented, knowledge of poetic symbols.

However, this has a direct relationship as well: the legalistic fallacies of justice and poetry uncover their cure at the hermeneutical stage. . In contrast, legalistic refers to the similarly improper, or truthful, understanding of the figurative and metaphorical components of poetry, specifically, what Socrates calls symbolic sense. Thus, if this feature of poetry is misinterpreted or overlooked, it must look like that poets tell lies and hence incorrectly depict reality. Hence, it is not quite appealing to use the prohibition of the poets as a contemplative affair that becomes vital to the examination of the nature of justice.

Specifically, as Plato determines the way in which an individual should identify with poetry, this consequently indicates how the nature of justice is to be interpreted. In other words, this paper argues that the philosophical interpretation of justice entails a ‘poeticization’, which implies that the essence of justice is a fact which can be revealed only in the identification of the philosopher in accordance to the poetic feature of existence. Hence, this paper claims that in The Republic, the issue of the essence of poetry provides an interpretive means through which the philosopher can be harmonized with the essence of justice.

This basic relationship reconstructs the very old conflict between philosophy and poetry, envisioning their bond as dynamic and fruitful, although argumentative, opposed. The argument of Aristotle seems to be an important revision of Plato’s thoughts on the connection between ‘phronesis’ as the statesman’s wisdom, and the capacity to put this wisdom in practice. Plato hence talks about the connection between ‘phronesis’ (wisdom) and ‘techne’ (art) in his conceptualization of justice.

Conclusions The absence of frankness in The

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis of Plato's Views of Justice and Poetry Essay”, n.d.)
Analysis of Plato's Views of Justice and Poetry Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1431670-what-is-appealing-and-what-is-not-so-appealing-in
(Analysis of Plato'S Views of Justice and Poetry Essay)
Analysis of Plato'S Views of Justice and Poetry Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1431670-what-is-appealing-and-what-is-not-so-appealing-in.
“Analysis of Plato'S Views of Justice and Poetry Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1431670-what-is-appealing-and-what-is-not-so-appealing-in.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Plato's Views of Justice and Poetry

Justice in Greek Philosophy

The immense dialogue in the Republic is opened by questioning the nature of justice.... Several definitions of justice are proposed which are found to be inadequate except that at least more emphasis is put on Sophist, Thrasymachus' definition.... Plato had quite a different view of justice; he believed that an answer exists that derives basically from reality's nature.... This work makes a critical view of plato's definition of the republic, justice, and its (justice's) application in society....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ideal Society in the Eyes of Locke and Swift

The Second Treatise reveals itself as a work that later grew into ideas of democracy and capitalism.... First it addresses the state of nature, wherein the individuals are in no compulsion to obey one another but are their own judge.... It is they who decide what the law of nature requires.... hellip; The treatise discuss basis for political doctrines, like, conquest and slavery, property, representative government, and the right of revolution, which is set forth in the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Ancient Political Thinkers - Socrates/Aristotle/Republic, Politics

380 BCE) provides the Socratic dialogue concerning the order and character of the City-State and the dialogues in the book, among Socrates and various Athenians and foreigners, are noted for the discussion about the… Significantly, the first book of The Republic offers proposes different definitions of justice such as returning debts owed and helping friends and Socrates finds these definitions as inadequate in certain contexts, because they lack rigidity.... Socrates makes an tant exploration of the nature of justice in which he incorporates the proposal, criticism, and rejection of several inadequate definitions of the concept....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Plato and More Definitive Understanding of Art and Philosophy

The following essay will seek to provide the reader with informed understanding of the inherent weaknesses of plato's approach to the issue of art/philosophy.... As one might expect, many pages are indeed entire pages of plato's work have been concentric on defining virtue in the means through which it can be maximized within our world.... Within the plato's republic, many definitions are put forward with regards to what can be defined as virtuous, good and beneficial form of art and/or artistic expression....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Platos Theory of Forms

hellip; The author states that the main characteristic of plato's work was the use of 'forms' which were the 'vehicle' for the 'exit' of knowledge to the real world by the representation of 'intangible' aspects.... In the paper “plato's Theory of Forms” the author focuses on plato's 'innovative' practice for capturing and imparting knowledge.... The importance of forms for plato's work is very significant.... The importance of forms for plato's work is very significant....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Plato and Derrida's Contribution to Literature

This essay “Plato and Derrida's Contribution to Literature” finds out that Plato was a pioneer in descriptive, analytical writing that expounds on complex principles such as justice and the immortality of the soul.... He also highlights the views of Havelock who in writing a preface to Plato's Republic, has emphasized the revolutionary impact of literacy on Greek and Roman societies.... The distinctive characteristics of Homeric poetry arise out of its close alignment with oral communicative methods, so that there is an economy which has been forced upon it, due to its close alignment with oral methods of composition....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

A Critique of Plato's Just Society Using the Notion of Fairness From John Rawls

The author states that Rawls views the just state as one that has equality as its aim.... By contrast, Rawls viewed inequality as created by the distribution of wealth, and while plato's ideal was a harmonious soul, Rawls ideal was equality itself.... Plato viewed a state as one that reflected the harmony of the three parts of the soul working together....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Nietzsche's View

nbsp;… This is what Nietzsche explains in his book Thus Spoke Zarathustra in the form of eternal recurrences pegged on the two distinct themes of justice and redemption.... This exposition is supported by Plato's view of justice where he supports paying of one's debts and assisting friends as the epitome of doing good in society.... This is demonstrated by Thus spoke Zarathustra, a complicated philosophical novel that explores among other things varying parables that predict the death of God and the destruction of moralist views....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us