StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of situation, by Phillip G. Zimbago - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
Zimbardo’s article reflects on a social experiment he conducted previously seeking to document the effect of psychological effects of the state of a prisoner and prison guard. The effects of social power of groups and whether direct confrontation can turn good people bad was…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of situation, by Phillip G. Zimbago
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of situation, by Phillip G. Zimbago"

Case Study: Law Case Study: Law Zimbardo’s article reflects on a social experiment he conducted previously seeking to documentthe effect of psychological effects of the state of a prisoner and prison guard. The effects of social power of groups and whether direct confrontation can turn good people bad was investigated. The said social experiment was conducted in the basement of Stanford Psychology Department. The article describes how participants were recruited for both prisoner and guard roles and the challenging scenarios to which they were exposed.

The author ends closes the article with conclusions drawn from a retrospective view of the occurrences during the experiment. In the analysis of the data he collected, Zimbardo considered how guards reacted when they perceived prisoners as dangerous. The analysis shows how the guards retaliated using abuses, strict rules and punishment. Sexual harassment is another form of punishment that was used by guards to command prisoners’ conformity. Zimbardo’s experiment has significance and relevance to the criminal justice system.

It helps the criminal justice to remain cognizant of the possible atrocities committed against suspects and prisoners both intentionally and unintentionally. Also important, the experiment depicts the negative psychological effects that certain extreme situations have on law enforcers such as prison guards. The Stanford Prison experiment has several aspects that are similar to the Abu Ghraib Situation and other that are different. Both happened in controlled setting, a prison, only that the Stanford Prison was not a real prison whereas the Abu Ghraib situation took place in a real detention centre.

The guards in the Stanford experiment and the captors in the Abu Ghraib situation coerced prisoners. Both cases involved similar forms of punishment and dehumanization. Such acts include stripping and making male prisoners wear women clothes. One of the differences between the two cases is that while the Stanford experiment used male prisoners only, Abu Ghraib prisoners were both male and female. Another difference is that the participants of Stanford experiment were paid but the Abu Ghraib prisoners were being tortured as a way of obtaining information from them and to punish them for alleged crimes.

Although they happened in different times and under different circumstances, the two cases arrived at practically the same conclusion because they both involved exposure to relatively similar extreme situational stressors for both prisoners and guards. The prisoners in both cases were exposed to elements of anonymity, dehumanization and coercion and as such were bound to respond in a relatively similar manner. Guards and captors were confronted with the need to dominate and subdue their subjects.

The outcomes of the two cases could have been different due to the fact that the participants of the Stanford experiment had knowledge that they were going to participant in a psychology experiment. As such, these participants could have faked their behaviours to suit what they thought the researchers were looking for. The author concluded that situational forces can overwhelm the good nature of individuals. Many people respect people they believe are in authority or have authority in a certain aspect of life.

Uncontrolled power can transform people’s characters in directions that are unpredictable. Zimbardo also concludes that evil fascinates because it demonstrates power and domination over others and not because of its consequences. I agree with Zimabardo’s conclusions because human beings can respond to situations in an evil way in an attempt to survive. Authority intimidates individuals and commands conformity as people try to avoid unpleasant consequences.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of Case Study”, n.d.)
Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1637151-revising-the-stanford-prison-experiment-a-lesson-in-the-power-of-situation-by-phillip-g-zimbago
(Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A Lesson in the Power of Case Study)
Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A Lesson in the Power of Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/1637151-revising-the-stanford-prison-experiment-a-lesson-in-the-power-of-situation-by-phillip-g-zimbago.
“Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A Lesson in the Power of Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1637151-revising-the-stanford-prison-experiment-a-lesson-in-the-power-of-situation-by-phillip-g-zimbago.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of situation, by Phillip G. Zimbago

The Stanford Prison Experiment

the stanford prison experiment the stanford prison experiment came out of class exercises in which I encouraged students to understand the dynamics of prison life.... Zimbardo's stanford prison experiment: This experiment was conducted to study the psychological impact of prison life on the prisoners.... As a part of this experiment, regular students were selected to perform the roles of prison guards and prisoners and were made to go through the exact same routines, as is usually observed in prisons....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Stanford Prison Experiment

Initial Post I believe that it was ethical to do the stanford prison experiment, because Philip G.... Initial Post I believe that it was ethical to do the stanford prison experiment, because Philip G.... “the stanford prison experiment: Still Powerful After All These Years.... stanford prison experiment.... hellip; In order to develop the ethical rigor of the experiment, the researchers “followed the guidelines of the stanford human subjects ethics committee that approved” the experiment (O'Toole, 1997)....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

The Stanford Prison Experiment

This study “the stanford prison experiment” describes a dramatic simulation of prison life conducted to study the behavior of good people when placed in an evil setting, to learn if humanity would prevail over evil or vice versa.... This was because the guards had grown to enjoy the power that they now held.... The negative emotions showed that the participants, both the prisoners and the guards, had internalized the situation or that they had started to believe in the situation....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Zimbardo Prison Experiment. The Dynamics of Attitude and Behaviour

the stanford prison experiment: Still powerful after all these years.... If I was more closely involved, as a subject, perhaps as a guard, I think I too might be carried away by the power and authority invested in me to 'guard' the 'prisoners'.... This chafing sensation, known as cognitive dissonance, is glaringly visible in the Zimbardo prison experiment.... 2006 from the stanford University News Service: http://www.... For the two-week experiment, a group of students were paid to participate in a simulated situation where half the randomly chosen students were 'prisoners' and the other half, 'guards'....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Stanford Prison Experiment

One of the most blatant ethical violations was the creating of conditions that prevented a participant from withdrawing from the study at… In a scientific study, participation of the subjects is purely voluntary and can be withdrawn at any time, even into the middle of the experiment.... The prisoner participants in this study however were treated so much like real prisoners that the reality of it all being Another significant violation in this study was the lack of impartiality and distance of the researcher from the experiment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Stanford Prison Study

the stanford prison experiment was a psychological study conducted at Stanford University and aimed at finding out the causes of disagreements between prisoners and prison warders.... ? the stanford prison experiment was a psychological study conducted at Stanford University and aimed at finding out the causes of disagreements between prisoners and prison warders.... (You may use your book) The ethical consideration of the stanford prison experiment included informed consent since the students volunteered to participate....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Applications of Stanford Prison Experiment

Modeled on Milgram's experiment on obedience, Philip Zimbardo and his colleagues set out to investigate the power of social situations in predisposing individuals' behaviors (APA, 2004).... Conducted in 1971 at Stanford University, the mock-prison experiment comprised of… The pre-selection process helped to screen for psychologically well-adjusted participants with no history of behavioral problems or genetically predisposed maladjustments.... The contextual factors include characteristics of a specific culture, state or the existence of a specific historical situation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Committing a Horrific Crime

the stanford prison experiment initiated by Phillip Zimbardo in 1971 forms the foundation of our understanding of the effects of situational forces on an individual.... the stanford prison experiment initiated by Phillip Zimbardo in 1971 forms the foundation of our understanding of the effects of situational forces on an individual.... The paper “stanford prison experiment by Philip Zimbardo - How Situational Forces Affect the Social Roles" is a fascinating example of a term paper on sociology....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us