StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Dynamic of Destruction - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Kramer's Dynamic of Destruction: Culture and Mass Killing in the First World War, published in 2007, is a tract on how the very nature of war changed drastically at the start of the twentieth century. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Dynamic of Destruction
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dynamic of Destruction"

Response to Dynamic of Destruction Kramer's Dynamic of Destruction: Culture and Mass Killing in the First World War, published in 2007, is a tract on how the very nature of war changed drastically at the start of the twentieth century. The author looks at various events from the beginning of the century, starting with the 1914 German raid of Louvain in Belgium, to highlight how war has become an all-encompassing phenomenon in which opposing sides compete to destroy not only each other's armies, but each other's ideologies, civilians, and culture.

However, Dynamic of Destruction is little more than a list of atrocities committed during the first half of the twentieth century – even if the individual events themselves are new to the reader, the manner in which they were performed have been repeated often enough that they seem a natural part of warfare to us. Kramer's thesis is so obvious as to be barely an argument at all. However, the horrors of the Great War were not limited to Germany – other countries, such as Italy and the Balkan nations, also committed shocking acts of brutality on their own as well as other peoples.

The chapter on 'German Singularity?' emphasizes that the “policy of absolute destruction” (114) was not unique to twentieth-century Germany, as many scholars have argued. Italy was one of the nations which perversely thrived under the influence of war. Its “eager … brutality and racism” (116) at the dawn of the century was the nation's attempt to “restore Italy's status as a Great Power” (116) as it invaded modern-day Libya. Even “Italy's bourgeois feminist movement renounced its pacifism” (118).

But Italian intervention in World War I proved unfortunate for the “gentle” troops, who were severely disciplined for their “lack of aggressive spirit” (127) – in Italy, unlike any other country during the war, 250 soldiers were executed as an example to others. One in twelve of the men serving were court-martialled (128). A more racist, though no less mindless, example of violence in the First World War was the situation in the Balkans, which both officially experienced genocide (the Armenian Genocide) and lesser, though still significant, crimes against humanity.

“The killing stopped somewhere short of genocide” (139) but in one case, 1159 of 1200 Bulgarian prisoners captured by Greek soldiers were massacred; in another, eighty-eight Greek villages were burnt to the ground over the course of three months for the cause of Turkish nationalism (145). Every victim was also a perpetrator. The combination of modern war technology and medieval healthcare and morals transformed the Balkans into a filthy orgy of death (136). However, the annihilation of another culture took not only the form of destruction, but also of construction: nationalist policies in the Austro-Hungarian Empire aimed to overrun colonies with German schools and Catholic churches, to reduce the influence of competing religions and languages (135).

This kind of warfare promoted a “cult of violence” (115), in which that which was previously sacred – civilians, for example, as well as cultural and historical artefacts – became legitimate targets of attack. As in the Armenian genocide, when Christians were “Islamicized” (Author, 167) in a conversion which saved their lives at the expense of their culture, countries which committed to war in the twentieth century did indeed commit the country, not just its army. The number of atrocities performed on innocent people and institutions suddenly became so widespread that it is now a part of everyday life – terrorism, the greatest threat to modern America, employs this very method of warfare, focusing on people who should be safe from such dangers.

However, I find Kramer's theory to be somewhat lacking. The book shows that he disagrees with the “special path” (114) of German history, which lead Germany straight from Bismarck to Hitler, but he provides no real alternative to this theory other than racism – furthermore, his argument is that racism was not unique to Germany, even though Nazism was. I disagree with his theory in that it ignores everything that is not directly related to it: it is simply not true that the only cause of war in the twentieth century was personal animosities towards marginalized groups of people.

The economic causes, and the non-violent effects, are important issues, and although it would be fair of Kramer to not focus on these, it is worryingly unacademical that he fails even to acknowledge them. Works Cited Kramer, Alan. Dynamic of Destruction: Culture and Mass Killing in the First World War. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007. Print. Lastname, Firstname. The book about Armenian genocide. Place: Publisher, Year. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dynamic of Destruction Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1414825-argumentative-response-essay
(Dynamic of Destruction Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1414825-argumentative-response-essay.
“Dynamic of Destruction Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1414825-argumentative-response-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dynamic of Destruction

The Armenian Genocide in Modern Politics

An essay "The Armenian Genocide in Modern Politics" will use evidence from primary sources given in the book about American genocide to link the underlying hatred of the genocide to Kramer's description of war as “total destruction” (Kramer), and its relationship to modern America.... Both the genocide and present US politics can be related to Kramer's idea that war in the twentieth century morphed into a “new style of warfare” (Sebag Montefiore) which he calls total destruction: conflict was no longer limited to the battleground but included the annihilation of civilians and culture as well....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Models of Communication and the Application to Daily Lives

… Communication models may be abstract metaphors of a dynamic process, it still provides at least a guideline, and validates communication ideas that would have otherwise been merely assumptions.... This idea turns them into distorting metaphors of communication, for it allows people to see communication opposite to its dynamic characteristic.... Therefore, communication models may be abstract metaphors of a dynamic process, it still provides at least a guideline, and validates communication ideas that would have otherwise been merely assumptions....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Entrepreneurship in the Creative Economy

Green community entrepreneurship: creative destruction in the social economy Globalization has enhanced entrepreneurship practices around the world.... Entrepreneurship practices are guided by various attitudes, and also face diverse and dynamic issues from time to time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Dynamics of Terrorism

Events of 11 September 2001 are logical corollary of massive violence and weapons of mass destruction available to the institution of State.... They even use weapons of mass destruction especially nuclear, biological and chemical weapons [NBCs] (1-22).... The twenty-first century is replete with "floodgates" of globalization and surging flames of terrorism....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Nuclear Weapons and the Dynamics of the Cold War

Over the years, the two countries would accumulate weapons of mass destruction without necessarily engaging in physical war-like attacks.... Weapons of mass destruction undoubtedly come with consequences that do not only affect the attacked party, but also the attacker.... Over the years, countries engage in social, economic, or political affairs that affect the underlying relationship in diverse and dynamic ways....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Mass Extinctions, Then and Now

This severity is majorly pretentious by the changes that are incorporated within the planet reflecting on habitat destruction, climate change, along the spread of invasive species (Mace & Lande, 1990)....  With this regard, the essay intends to elaborate on the different discriminations that are applicable by science on the issues of mass destruction.... Through the different issues that hint towards mass destruction, the essay elaborates on the needs of management of different attributes related to the concerns that are attached with the severe destructive attribute of mass destruction and provident insight towards the same....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Conflict is Never Good

This paper "Conflict is Never Good" discusses general observations to challenge the notion that no conflict is good, and that nothing good ever comes out of conflict regardless of the manner of its handling.... In sports competitions, for instance, conflict allows for people to excel at particular skills....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Ecosystems in Todmorden Mills Park

hellip; The author states that environmental protection is vital as it reduces the destruction of the network and also ensures that the same is restored to its original state for the overall purpose of survival of all.... In the paper “Ecosystems in Todmorden Mills Park” the author provides a description of the meadow and the woodland in Todmorden Mills Park helps in understanding the ecosystem, ecotone's structure, function and the dynamics of the named ecosystems....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us