StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Inhumane - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The focus of this paper is on the Great Wall of America, hereinafter called the Wall, between the United States and Mexico is the antithesis to the Statue of Liberty, a symbol for liberty for the tired and the oppressed people, including immigrants…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Inhumane
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Inhumane"

26 March Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Inhumane The Great Wall of America, hereinafter called the Wall, between the United States and Mexico is the anti-thesis to the Statue of Liberty, a symbol for liberty for the tired and the oppressed people, including immigrants. Illegal immigration has negative effects on employment and social welfare, but it cannot be stopped through a physical barrier, no matter how long and high it is. The government is only wasting taxpayers’ money by building a long and high wall around it, since smugglers and illegal immigrants will find ways to enter the U.S. Americans must oppose the Great Wall of America because it is not an effective and efficient solution to illegal immigration, it promotes nativism that borders racism, and it results to inhumane consequences that goes against the universal right to work and live in other nations. The Wall is too expensive, yet ineffective, in curbing illegal immigration. The Wall is too costly, and it is not even completed in a consistent manner. Wayne A. Cornelius from the University of California at San Diego complains of the endless costs of building the wall: “Upward of $25 billion has been spent on border fortification since 1993, but we have little to show for it beyond photo ops for anti-immigration politicians.” These funds are approved by Congress, but the expenses will never end because of the large area of territory needed to build the Wall and to maintain it. Furthermore, the Wall will not stop immigrants, who are deeply driven to cross physical barriers because of socio-economic reasons. David Von Drehle, a reporter for Time, notes that immigrants will seek for other ways to illegally enter America: “Crossings didnt stop--they moved” (2). People will not stop in searching for means to breach the Wall, especially when they have nothing to lose. Furthermore, a wall, no matter how solid or guarded it is, cannot stop the ingenuity of human smugglers. Their business is to move people illegally across borders, and not even the Great Wall can stop them: “Smugglers like to cut this fence with torches, then carefully put everything back in place so the border patrol wont notice” (Von Drehle 2). When obstacles exist, human smugglers use other modes of getting people across the border. Thus, the present Wall is inefficient and not significantly effective in stopping illegal immigration. Apart from being an ineffective and expensive way of controlling immigration, the Wall promotes sentiments of nativism that can lead to racism. Richard Rodriguez, a news writer for Los Angeles Times, argues that a physical wall creates a psychological source of anxiety for American citizens: “Once the wall is in place, anxiety about the coming outsider changes to an anxiety about who belongs within” (2). Americans might soon see immigrants, including legal ones, as the “other” who must be controlled and weakened. The other has the face of Mexicans, which can result to racism in the long run. The Wall acts as a way of dividing people from one another, highlighting differences instead of common interests. People have a right to geographical mobility, and to not endure greater risks in finding U.S. employment. People have the universal right to work and to reside in areas where they are needed. If Americans can go to Mexico to live and/or work there, then Mexicans also have the right to reside and work in the U.S. As long as a market exists for Mexican workers, they will keep on coming into the U.S. Furthermore, the Wall has only led to inhumane consequences, such as increased fees for human smuggling. Cornelius asserts: “People-smugglers’ fees have more than tripled as tougher U.S. border enforcement has increased the demand for their services.” The demand for border crossing increased, as well as prices, because of the Wall. Moreover, it is inhumane to create walls that force desperate individuals to take greater risks. Von Drehle states that “the fence is funneling migrants into a life-threatening desert” (2). Because of the wall, illegal immigrants go through riskier lengths to pass the border. The Wall is an inhumane way of controlling immigration, when other alternatives exist. Supporters of the Great Wall assert that it effectively reduces illegal immigration, and the financial costs are well worth it. The Wall is a work in progress that works. Von Drehle notes that Yuma’s sector in Arizona decreased crossings by approximately 80% (2). Jan C. Ting of Temple University Beasley School of Law highlights the advantages of the Wall: “Any reduction in illegal border crossing is significant, because it’s always cheaper to prevent violations of law than to pursue, process, and prosecute after the fact.” The Wall can deter illegal immigrants because it is a tangible hindrance to their mobility. Indeed, some areas of the Wall are working, but not because of the wall alone, but due to the combination of the right number of dedicated people, resources, technology, judicial, and community support. Furthermore, illegal immigrants will continue crossing the border, despite the wall, because of the simple fact that they can find better paying jobs in America. Lawrence Downes puts it bluntly in his editorial notes for The New York Times: “the illegal flow continues north…pulled by the mightiest economy on earth, obeying one law that Congress and Mr. Chertoff [head of homeland security] could never repeal, that of supply and demand.” Thus, the Wall does not serve its purpose when employers continue to hire illegal workers without being stopped or punished. The Wall is an ineffective and costly band-aid to the illegal immigration issue. The main reason that people enter the U.S., even crossing the wall in devious ways, is because work is waiting for them on the other side. As long as American employers give them work, they will continue torching or tunneling into the border. The Wall is not the best and most humane solution to illegal immigration, and it is time that the U.S. government focuses on controlling the employers of illegal immigrants, not the immigrants themselves. Works Cited Cornelius, Wayne A. “Pro: Physical Obstacles Don’t Work.” No Great Wall for Mexico. The Debate Room. BusinessWeek.com, Feb. 2008. Web. 23 Mar. 2012. . Downes, Lawrence. “The Not-So-Great Wall of Mexico.” The New York Times, 20 Apr. 2008. Web. 23 Mar. 2012. < http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/20/opinion/20sun4.html?_r=0>. Rodriguez, Richard. “The ‘Great Wall of America’ and the Threat from Within.” Los Angeles Times, 5 Sept. 2010. Web. 23 Mar. 2012. . Ting, Jan C. “Con: Prevent and Remedy.” No Great Wall for Mexico. The Debate Room. BusinessWeek.com, Feb. 2008. Web. 23 Mar. 2012. . Von Drehle, David. “The Great Wall of America.” Time, 19 June 2008. < http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1816488,00.html>. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Literature review”, n.d.)
Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Literature review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1618734-argument-essay-mini-research-paper-about-immigration-specific-topics-included-in-instructions
(Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Literature Review)
Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Literature Review. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1618734-argument-essay-mini-research-paper-about-immigration-specific-topics-included-in-instructions.
“Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Literature Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1618734-argument-essay-mini-research-paper-about-immigration-specific-topics-included-in-instructions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Against the Great Wall of America: Inefficient, Ineffective, and Inhumane

The World Bank of the Unheard

WB was intended for the “war -ravaged countries of Europe—and the poorer countries of Latin america, and Africa” (Birdsall 51).... World Bank (WB) has over the years become known to some of its proponents as a credit world club (Birdsall 50).... It resembles a type of a credit union where its members are countries (Birdsall 50)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

What Are the Appropriate Channels for William to Seek Any Compensation for Loss of Job

hellip; Discrimination In accordance with UK law, which came into being on 1st October 2006, no employer can turn down the request of an employee on the basis of age; neither passes insulting remarks against the employee as we have seen in the case of William.... In order to make his case strong against discriminatory attitude by the employer and the harassment at work premise, William may adopt the following course a) keep a diary of the incidents that took place b) witnesses of co workers c) confront harassment d) have a word with HR and e) discuss the matter with Union Representative (Harris, et al 61)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Illegal Drugs as Problematic Issue

This is evidenced by the fact that the great majority of youths who use illegal drugs choose the least harmful.... america's war against recreational drugs is an example of good intentions gone terribly wrong.... Illegal drugs are a problematic issue that has caused political and cultural divides among all nations of the world in addition to the societies within them....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Role of the Mentor in Creating Healthy Learning Environment

On the other hand the mentor should take guard against manipulating the mentee by allowing for self regulation by the student which may be achieved by letting the learner set own goals, carry out a self observation, have a self judgment of what is right or wrong and allow for self reaction....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Roles of the Police Dogs

In North america, police dogs are referred to as canines with the dogs which are specifically trained being regarded as part of the law… They are instrumental in assisting the police and other law enforcement people in their roles.... The German shepherd is the most common breed used due to its qualities such as sharpness and good senses needed in the tasks it will be required to perform....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Workings of the Multinational Organization

This would mean that multinationals have to invest in not only a change in strategy over a period of time but also carry out related activities like proper methods of hiring, removing inefficient employees, investing a little more on the units which are ready to default as well as strengthen the cash cow strategic unit of the company, all the same.... In this paper, my role is of a senior HR manager who is representing a multinational company within my country of origin and my task is to recruit staff for our subsidiaries in North america, Africa and the Arab region....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Culture and Dictators

The idea he presented that Aryan's produce great personality is highly controversial.... Hitler wants to give the impression that all things great were produced by Germans.... This coursework "Culture and Dictators" focuses on democracy that had been the most successful kind of ruling the world has ever seen....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Planning Process and Consultation

And therefore just like the scientific hypothesis, they must be checked against the facts and assumptions about the changes foreseeable in the future.... This assignment "Planning Process and Consultation" presents activity of system analysis that bases its application on the fact that the activities that are stipulated are interrelated....
16 Pages (4000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us