StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should the instant replay used in the NFL be applied to other sports - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper outlines the existing problems of the instant replay used in the NFL and also it represents the solutions and advantages. Replays solve the problem of cheating from players. In sports where we emphasize cheating is unacceptable, it becomes illogical not to use replays…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
Should the instant replay used in the NFL be applied to other sports
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should the instant replay used in the NFL be applied to other sports"

Introduction Instant replay can be defined as the act of replaying video footages of an activity or event immediately after it occurs, (Berman 1683). In broadcasting sports events, these replays highlight a passage of play which was considered remarkable or was unclear in the first instance. In some organizations, which deal with sports, referees are allowed to consult these replays before making a crucial decision, (Gamache 101). Some sporting organizations do not. When a referee is allowed to consult with these replay footages, then it is called video refereeing, instant replay official video umpire, television match official and third umpire. There are organizations that allow use of video only after the game, (Wiederhold and W Sutphen 54). In this case, the video footage is used as the evident of taking a particular decision e.g. misconduct. In 1955, hockey night, in Canada, was able to broadcast on CBC television. By that time, producer George Retzlaff used a kinescope replay which was also known as wet film. It used to air minutes later. A few years later, ABC initiated the slow motion replay, (Kramer 194). In 1960 during the winter Olympics, officials requested CBS to allow them review a videotape of men’s salmon race. This was due to a controversy touching on one skier. It had been alleged that the skier missed a gate. One of the members of the staff, Tony Verna, returned to the CBS New York headquarters and developed the first instant play system. This system debuted at the army-navy game in 1963. This became the source of inspiration for the CBS to develop instant replay. Part 1: Problems that exist. Instant replays were necessitated by the need to be accurate, (Verna 21). There was a problem when teams were awarded titles and trophies they did not deserve. One point can make a significant difference, (Wiederhold and W Sutphen 54). One score can be the difference between the winner and the loser. It has been observed that teams have been given points they did not score. All because the referee thought the ball went past the score line. In 2010 FIFA world cup, for instance, in South Africa when England was playing against Germany England was denied a goal by the referees. Yet replays confirmed the ball went past the goal line. Before a team wins a championship, it costs the team a lot of money, effort and time, (Kramer 194). Teams invest up to millions of dollars in these activities so that they can win. When an unfair decision by a referee denies a team a crucial victory, then it causes anger and frustrations. Yet the referees cannot be in every place within the field of play, (Wiederhold and W Sutphen 54). The other problem involved cases of discipline in the field of play. There are instances in which players attack each other in a way that is malicious, (Verna 21). Some of those incidences can result to injuries. The referees are not always in a position a see some of these incidences as they happen. Most of these incidences are captured by video cameras. These footages are aired in the course of the game, (Gamache 101). This sparks a wave of outrage from fans and supporters. Sometimes the referees are accused of being biased. This happen when it is perceived that the referee is being unfair to one team. The referees need to be at a position to see things as they happen in the field of play. Referees involve instant replay technology. Instant play helps to sort of some of these challenges. Tournaments must be a fair platform. This is because they must show genuine effort being rewarded. Technology must be used to solve the problems that exist if it has to make sense to us. There should be a way of spotting and monitoring all the incidences in the course of the game. This makes sure that all cases that require disciplinary action as handled in the right way, (Verna 21). The other serious problem is on the bases of security of the players in the field. This also extends to the security of the fans watching the game in the field. There have been instances when fans run into the field of play and attack the players. This happens by wrestling a player before the security team reacts. In some cases, objects are thrown at the players. Sometimes it is the referee being attacked by angry fans, (Kramer 194). Through the use of replays, the security team is can spot the actual perpetrators of these acts. When players fight and the whole incident deteriorate into a mob fight, the instant replays help in finding out the instigators. Replays give a sense if direction in such occurrences. There are instances where racial attacks have been directed to players, or coaches have become involved in fights with players while on the bench, (Gamache 101). All these events are captured and replayed for people to watch and know. All these challenges need to be monitored closely. This shall make people more involved since there is a perceived justice in the refereeing of the game. Part 2: solutions and advantages Replays solve the problem of cheating from players. In sports where we emphasize cheating is unacceptable, it becomes illogical not to use replays, (Hanson 51). There is no much controversy as to whether the referee can fail to spot some incidences of cheating, (Kramer 194). There are times players do unpleasant things and the referee, no matter how professional he may be, fails to spot, (Verna 21). We have seen players using hands where they are supposed to be using feet and vice versa. Players hit each other without any good reason. Some of the injuries end up destroying a player’s career. We have to minimize an unfair advantage. For instance, a team invests millions of dollars into a championship final, (Berman 1683). Afterwards, the anticipated final comes, and after too much publicity the rival teams and fans meet to play. Five minutes into the game, a player pretends to have been unfairly hit by another player. Upon watching instant replay, we see that the two players never had contact in the first place. Yet one of the players is off leaving the rival team with an outright unfair advantage. Such instances can be eliminated or at least minimized. The pain and anguish that the player, team and even fans go through is sometimes too much, yet it is avoidable. Replay is about players, fans and the teams. Teams stay for long without winning major tournaments yet fans stick by their teams no matter what. The other solution is accurate awarding of points and marks or score, (Wiederhold and W Sutphen 54). In hockey, for example, instant replays are used show the movement of the ball near the goal line. The same case happens in basketball, where instant replays help to show whether the ball had gone from the palms of the player earlier than time ran out on him, (Hanson 51). It is intriguing to note that, in both cases, there is a no or yes verdict, (Verna 21). This means that, at the end of the game the losers have none to blame. The team retreats and works hard to improve on the next game. If a team feels it lost unfairly, then it can easily become demoralized. This is because a refereeing mistake can cost a team a place in history of successful teams. In extreme cases, referees have been accused of conspiracy against some teams. Within the past ten years, the national football and hockey leagues have adopted the use of instant replays to avoid altercations, (Kramer 194). There altercations sometimes arise from a mistaken call during the time the game is ongoing. The national basketball association also uses it too, (Verna 21). Some of these altercations give rise to fights on the pitch which spills into the fans. This leads to greater loses. Such incidents lead to security breaches. Replays have a proactive role, (Hanson 51). This helps to avert unnecessary anger. They convince the coaches, players and fans that they won or lost fairly and, therefore, there is no need for violence, (Gamache 101). While replays can be used to monitor the behavior of fans with in the stadium, and to assist in arresting violent fans, it has a bigger role in preventing ugly instances from happening. Instants replays have helped in preventing deaths. How? Diehard fans are known to commit suicide where there teams go through an extreme fate. The same case applies to players. There is a history of players committing suicide just because a life changing call was made. Don Moore, of the American league, took his life in 1980’s. This was subsequent to blowing match five of the competition to the ‘red sox’ team. There could have been other reasons that led to this. However, a missed call could end up having the same result. Bad calls are known to change the course of history. Therefore, instant replay helps in assuring players and fans that something is being done about their concerns, (Berman 1683). This is because justice must be seen to be done. Too many coaches, players and fans this is what fair play is all about. Some of these parties do not mind the delays involved as long as their concerns are being addressed. Works Cited Gamache, Ray. A History of Sports Highlights: Replayed Plays from Edison to ESPN. 1st ed. McFarland, 2010. Print. 5 Sept. 2012. . Kramer, Jerry. Instant Replay: The Green Bay Diary of Jerry Kramer. 2nd ed. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, 2006. Print. 5 Sept. 2012. . Verna, Tonny. Instant Replay: The Day That Changed Sports Forever. 1st ed. Creative Book Pub International, 2008. Web. 5 Sept. 2012. . Wiederhold, Arthur, and Charles W. W Sutphen. instant replay. 1st ed. iuniverse, 2001. Print. 5 Sept. 2012. . Hanson, Christopher. "instant replay." The Instant Replay Time and Time Again 28.2 (2008): 51-60. Web. 5 Sept. 2012. . Berman*, Mitchell N. "Instant Replay in the NCAA: The Three Verdict System ............." replay 99.1 (2011): 1683-1742. Web. 5 Sept. 2012. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should the instant replay used in the NFL be applied to other sports Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1456592-should-the-instant-replay-used-in-the-nfl-be
(Should the Instant Replay Used in the NFL Be Applied to Other Sports Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1456592-should-the-instant-replay-used-in-the-nfl-be.
“Should the Instant Replay Used in the NFL Be Applied to Other Sports Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sports-and-recreation/1456592-should-the-instant-replay-used-in-the-nfl-be.
  • Cited: 3 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the instant replay used in the NFL be applied to other sports

Solar Cooling Technology in Football Stadiums

It is this hint that brought about the cooling technology utilizing solar energy which could be applied in large capacity buildings i.... But I must forewarn before we delve in depth into this research work, that if the subject matter is not understood properly, if the rudiments and nitty gritties of the technology are not clearly explained, if the step by step process of the workability of the technology are not clearly defined, if the dimensions of operations as projected by Qater sports development ministry are not accurately modified etc....
40 Pages (10000 words) Dissertation

Media for Marketing and Advertising

Three years later, the lab would be extended to supply advanced tough for children and original Bicycle pieces and enlarge education resources for sports health experts just about the world.... Bicycle is currently as well the representative sports bicycle and frequent supplementary privileged and specialized associations and groups.... ollowing years of suspicious study by the workers next to GSSI into the requirements of children involved in high-command guidance and antagonism, Bicycle initiated the Bicycle Performance succession, and privileged row of sports entertainment products, in 2001 (McCann 2003)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

USA Sports Law

… USA sports Law As a legal counsel, I am more interested on the legal issues that surround this incident, more than the economical or social implications of the same.... The following are the issues that are at play here: If Sharman's father sues the club, he will be doing so under the "Professional sports Torts Act" (Epstein, 2008).... sports torts are "legal actions taken against professional athletes, teams, organizations and other parties in the sports field for a civil wrong done against and individual" (Epstein, 2008)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

Marketing Plan Final evaluation

Video games like MANU, sports, car racing, pacman, NBA, wrestling, diddy kong, rugby, baseball, tetris, NHL, GTA and hockey are also preferred but in lesser number.... The maximum choice was given to guitar hero (13), DRR (12), madden nfl (8), and WII (8) (Graph 3).... Wetstock control or Wetstock management is a term often used to describe stock reconciliation.... However wetstock management in its broadest description starts when fuel is delivered to the petrol… on by road tanker, offloaded into underground storage tanks and ultimately supplied through underground pipe work to fuel dispensers, which are then used either by attendants or motorists to refuel vehicle fuel tanks1....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A critical review of Homophobia in football: the FA and clubs' response

There are still many eople who dont accept homophobia these days, but in football and other sports it has become much more evident, as fans shout homophobic insults at players, referees, opposing fans and others.... The treatment of it has undergone tremendous changes in the past century, yet in the field of sports, and particularly in football, the… To many, a gay football player sounds fictitious and impossible since football (and sports in general) is so closely related to masculinity and strength, things that some people think gays dont have....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Salaries of Professional Athletes

nbsp; Salaries of professional athletes from the NBA, MLB, NHL, and the nfl seem to increase per year and for each athlete.... nbsp; The latest figures from the 2007-2008 sports season reveal that Alex Rodriguez was paid $28 million; Jason Giambi, $24 million; Shaquille O'Neal, $21 million; Kevin Garnett, $23.... nbsp; On one hand, it contends that professional athletes are worth their high salaries because sports consumerism drives or dictates the terms of this market....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Media for Marketing and Advertising

In the years with the intention of pursuing, progressively NFL groups started leaving Bicycle on the tangential of their games along with performances, later Bicycle became the official sports bicycle of the nfl a title it holds to this day.... Cade and his team executed assiduously to expand the wheeling formula with the purpose of would become Bicycle; to carry out the technical study in the quarter of work out discipline sports entertainment (Rudy 2010).... Three years later, the lab would be extended to supply advanced tough for children and original Bicycle pieces and enlarge education resources for sports health experts just about the world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Economic Super-Structure of the Spectacle: the Relationship Between the Leagues and the Networks

The spectacles that will be considered will be modern, professional sports.... Spectator sports are a significant factor in the lives of modern Americans, particularly urban Americans.... It is, despite the differing meanings, today related to spectacles used as a synonym for eyeglasses....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us