StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Corporate Governance Models - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay presents the comparison of the two models of corporate governance: Shareholder value and Stakeholder, as companies have now begun to realize that employees constitute an important part of the corporate community in addition to the shareholders…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Corporate Governance Models
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Corporate Governance Models"

SHAREHOLDER VALUE MODEL & STAKEHOLDER MODEL Below is a comparison of the two models of corporate governance: Shareholder value and Stakeholder. [Source: Governance Models] The shareholder value is designed in such a way that the only the shareholders and executives will earn high returns on the stocks they have invested. As seen above, the shareholder value focuses wholly on the shareholders and ignores the other stakeholders of the company such as employees, suppliers and customers. As the time passed and new developments came about in corporate governance, the theory underlying the shareholder value model changed to a certain extent but the theory is still followed as the new theory ‘The Stakeholder Model’ are yet fully developed.

But this model keeps in view all the stakeholders related to the company especially the employees. TRANSFER OF VOTING AND CASH-FLOW RIGHTS TO EMPLOYEES Companies have now begun to realize that employees constitute an important part in the corporate community in addition to the shareholders. Due to the continuation of the shareholder value model in this globalization era, employees are still considered as a commodities rather than assets for the company. Keeping this factor in view, companies that follow this model tend to have higher employee turnover, are not willing to induce in long-term contracts and therefore invest less in employee training.

This system of corporate governance tends to have a direct bearing on pay inequality. Cash flow rights mean the portion of a portfolio company’s equity value that different shareholder and management have a claim to. On the other hand, voting rights measure the percentage of votes that shareholders and management have to effect corporate decisions. The decisions are mostly based on majority rule. ESOP was designed to better align the interests of employees and the managers by giving them a right in the company’s decision making as shareholders.

As the share’s price rise, the options become more valuable to the employees. Under the shareholder model, it is believed that as the management is focused on one objective of maximizing shareholders’ wealth, the strategies are planned in that direction and ultimately increases the total wealth of the firm. Thus, everyone in the firm can get a bigger share of the pie if the pie is large. Therefore this model, does not believe in transferring the rights of voting and cash-flows to the employees.

A principle of proportional ownership has being identified by the EC as an important factor that could reform the internal markets. It is ‘one share, one vote’ rule which seeks to strengthen the shareholder rights and thus weakening the protection of the employees. All the measures that are being undertaken to implement this principle create an undesirable wedge between the voting and cash-flow rights. The stakeholder model characterizes a socialist worldview. But by following the stakeholder model of corporate governance, employees can get the voting and cash-flow rights as they are considered to be as asset like any other shareholder.

The new stakeholder model addresses the need to specify the rights of employees, customers, suppliers and such; simplify their role in corporate governance; and establish instruments to protect their interests. Employees are allowed to participate in corporate governance in their capacity as owners. The model that the firms now use has changed from shareholder value model to stakeholder model of corporate governance as the shareholders do not hold the company’s stock for a long-term. Short-term shareholders are not dedicated to the long-term health of the company therefore there is not enough of a voice to hold corporate directors accountable for their decisions.

If the employees are also included in the voting and other decisions of the firm, it should actually improve shareholder value over the long term which is one of the goals of stakeholder model. REFERENCES Adams, R, Ferreira, D, 2007, One Share, One Vote: Empirical Evidence. European Corporate Governance Institute. Available from: [26 January, 2009]. Aglietta, M, Rebérioux, A (2005), Corporate Governance Adrift: A critique of shareholder value, [26 January, 2009]. Boatright, J. 2006. What’s wrong—and what’s Right—with Stakeholder Management, Journal of Private Enterprise. Vol. XXI, Available from: [26 January, 2009].

Eastman, Santaro. Voting for Your Boss: An Economic Argument for Workplace Democracy. Rutgers Business School. Available from [26 January, 2009]. Galia, D. Wiener, Z. 2008. Stakeholders and the composition of the voting rights of the board of directors. Journal of Corporate Finance 14 (2008) 107–117. Available from: [26 January, 2009]. Jacoby, S. Corporate Governance, Risk & Inequality in Japan and the United States. UCLA Anderson. Available from: < http://www.anderson.ucla.edu/x8018.xml> [26 January, 2009].

Jensen, M. Value Maximization, Stakeholder Theory, and Corporate Objective Function. European Financial Management, Vol.7, No.3, 2001. Available from 26 January, 2009]. Tenev, Zhang, Brefort. Corporate Governance and Enterprise Reform in China. International Finance Corporation. ISBN 0-8213-5136-2. [26 January, 2009] Beyond ‘Control and Alignment’: Non-economic Objectives and Relational Governance Available from: [26 January, 2009]. Governance Models. International Chamber of Commerce. Available from: [26 January, 2009]

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Corporate Governance Models Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Corporate Governance Models Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1551439-corporate-governance-models
(Corporate Governance Models Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Corporate Governance Models Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1551439-corporate-governance-models.
“Corporate Governance Models Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1551439-corporate-governance-models.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Corporate Governance Models

Nonprofit-Business Partnerships as a Means of Implementing CSR

The emphasis on stakeholder theory marks a dramatic shift in Corporate Governance Models.... The first part of this paper examines and analyses traditional CRS models within the corporate governance constructs of a company.... Traditional CSR as a Part of corporate governance Shareholder maximisation theory dictates that business organizations exist for the mere purpose of maximising profits for the benefit of their shareholders.... However, corporate scandals and collapses have turned attention toward the issue of satisfactory corporate governance, accountability, transparency and trust....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Successful Corporate Governance: Business Financial and Public Accomplishment

Through the turning of millennium however, flow of occurrences provided a need to center public focus on a high-flying subject 'The corporate governance' with reference to its vital significance for global economy.... Accordingly, government, different dictatorial boards and the media expanded the extent of their inspection further than the aberrant companies. This paper is proposed to help analyze the subject matter of corporate governance.... Then it endeavors to establish a practical relationship between organizational perspectives and corporate governance taking into consideration prospects of organizational speculations and transaction cost economics....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Reforming Corporate Governance - Finance and Corporate Governance Systems

There is a large number of independence impairments which can be observed quite often in the Corporate Governance Models from all over the globe.... nbsp;… Openness and freedom have a different meaning both in the European governance models, as well as in the US model, and it has to be established and defended against a different set of interests.... nbsp; Variations present in these areas show some of the considerable differences among all the governance models....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

Corporate Governance in the USA

The main body of the paper carries out a comparison of the UK and the US Corporate Governance Models.... This paper compares and assesses the extent to which the recommendations and principles of corporate governance have been implemented in the United Kingdom and the United States of America.... It specifically assesses the effect of corporate governance implementation on controlling… The introduction section gives general principles and concepts about corporate governance....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Corporate Governance in Poland

lf-regulation in the global business markets has resulted in the establishment and standardisation of corporate governance policies and codes (Maassen, Bosch and Volberda, 2004).... This paper will explore the concept of corporate governance in Poland drawing from the privatisation movement of the 1990s, which resulted in massive changes in the corporate structure and organization, thereby prompting the practice of corporate governance in the country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

PhD Finance - Effects of Corporate Governance

However, apart from this model, many organizations have developed good Corporate Governance Models which can be adopted by other companies thereby enabling them to maximize their firm's value.... Today's organizations have come up with various policies, processes and structures which create a corporate governance system (Cutting & Kouzmin, 2011, p.... EFFECTS OF corporate governance By Effects of corporate governance Today's organizations have come up with various policies, processes and structures which create a corporate governance system (Cutting & Kouzmin, 2011, p....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Openness Issue in the US and Europe

Variations present in these areas show some of the considerable differences among all the governance models.... hellip; corporate governance remains difficult to perceive the issue for business students all over.... Ethical behavior is expected from everyone participating in the corporate governance process and inevitably from the directors and executives.... corporate governance basically is all about the characteristics of a governing process....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Corporate Governance Systems: A Model Based on Shareholder Primacy

The paper “corporate governance Systems: A Model Based on Shareholder Primacy” has examined the statement that there is a convergence of the corporate governance systems towards shareholder primacy and dispersed ownership structure.... hellip; The author states that corporate governance refers to the rules, processes, systems, and laws that govern and direct the operations and policies.... corporate governance is also about the ethical behavior of a firm....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us