StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mexican Immigration and American Identity - Case Study Example

Summary
The paper "Mexican Immigration and American Identity" tells us about America’s National Identity. Such settlers were predominantly white, British, and Protestant and the basic elements of their Anglo-Protestant culture include ‘[…] the English language…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Mexican Immigration and American Identity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mexican Immigration and American Identity"

Mexican Immigration and American Identity Aryna Da Silva Academia Research February 26, Mexican Immigration and American Identity In ‘Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity’ (2004), Samuel P. Huntington argues that the American national identity was formed and shaped according to values and institutions introduced by the first settlers from the 17th and 18th century. Such settlers were predominantly white, British, and Protestant and the basic elements of their Anglo-Protestant culture include ‘[…] the English language; Christianity; religious commitment; English concepts of the rule of law, including the responsibility of rulers and the rights of individuals; and dissenting Protestant values of individualism, the work ethic, and the belief that humans have the ability and the duty to try to create a heaven on earth […]’. According to the author, even though other values and principles of non-Protestant immigrants have helped to shape and modified this concept, most Americans accept these basic elements of an Anglo-Protestant culture as the key defining elements of their national identity. Yet, the author states that in the last decades of the 20th century, this culture has been challenged by a context of globalization and ideas of multiculturalism and diversity. The rise of groups that focus on race, ethnicity, and gender over a more general national identity are regarded as a threat to ‘the country’s cultural and political integrity’. Huntington views immigration from Latin America, especially from Mexico, as the single largest threat to the American identity. This due to a combination of six unique characteristics that differentiate contemporary Mexican immigration from past immigrant flows, being contiguity (boarder proximity), scale (steadily increasing numbers), illegality (illegal entry and permanence into the country), regional concentration (particularly concentrated in California and the Southwest), persistence (no signs of decline over the years), and historical presence (historical claim to the US territory). The boarder proximity with Mexico in the Southwest region encourages immigration and illegal entry into the U.S., which results in the steady increase of Mexican immigration throughout the 20th century. Similarly, it increases the concentration of Mexican immigrants in that area of the country and the illegal characteristics of the flow. Since the conditions creating such immigration (economic conditions of Mexico, boarder proximity, etc) are unlikely to change, the flow is expected to persist. These factors, the author argues, differentiate the Mexican contingent from previous immigrant groups and are likely to hinder the assimilation of Mexicans into the United States culture. One of the author’s main arguments defending the poor assimilation of Mexican immigrants into the U.S. society is the persistent use of their native language through successive generations. Huntington admits that statistics on English proficiency and Spanish preservation are limited and ambiguous. Nevertheless, the author insists that particular characteristics of the flow – scale, persistence and concentration – are likely to encourage the perpetuation of Spanish among successive generations of immigrants. Huntington considers that Spanish retention has a negative impact on the assimilation of the new culture even when proficiency in English is achieved. In addition, bilingualism would affect earnings and put English-only families in disadvantage within the job market. Finally, the concentration of Mexicans in certain areas transform portions of the country into bilingual and bicultural areas, reinforcing Mexican values over the traditional Anglo-Protestant values, which, according to the author, threatens the integrity of the nation, possibly dividing the nation ‘into a country of two languages and two cultures’. From my point of view, Huntington’s concept of the American identity is limited and excludes a great portion of the nation’s cultural and ethnic background. The author’s definition of identity as ‘the product of the distinct Anglo-Protestant culture of the founding settlers’ may be identified with what Ronald Takaki (1993: 4) calls ‘Master Narrative of American History’. According to Takaki, the concept that white Europeans settled the U.S. is an inaccurate but powerful, popular, and common story amongst preeminent scholars, used to create the traditional view of the national identity. This story, however, excludes the African population enslaved and brought to the country since the 17th century; it excludes the Chinese immigrants, whom Takaki affirms to have arrived in the U.S. before many Europeans (1993:7); it also excludes the Irish immigrants, a Catholic group arriving in the country as early as the 17th century (1993:8); it excludes the Native Americans, the Jewish, the Japanese, the Mexicans, to name a few. In fact, one can question if Huntington’s concept of American identity is based on exclusion rather than inclusion. The Mexicans, for instance, were in the Southwest since before the first white settlers arrived given that large sections of Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, Utah, and California were part of the Mexican territory before they were lost in the Mexican-American wars of the 19th century. According to Takaki, thousands of Mexicans were permitted to remain in the United States after the war and were used as workers in ranching, agriculture, railroad construction and in the mining industry. While Anglo workers were employed as managers, foremen, and other skilled white-collar occupations, the Mexicans were mainly employed in blue-collar, manual and dangerous type of work. However, as the Great Depression reduced the need for labor and Mexicans were increasing in numbers by continuously entering the country and by birth rate, Takaki notes that Mexicans began being blamed for Anglo unemployment. There was thus an increasing public debate regarding a threat to the Anglo cultural homogeneity. Although employers insisted on the need for Mexican unskilled labor, repatriation programs were put in place to return such laborers to their homeland once their work was no longer needed. The Mexican threat to the American identity and cultural integrity discussed by Huntington is therefore not a new debate as it can be traced back to the early decades of the 20th century. It is however, a threat to an inaccurate concept of identity, a concept based on the exclusion of America’s diversity and multicultural roots. In ‘Brown: The Last Discovery of America’ (2002), Richard Rodriguez uses the colour ‘brown’ to illustrate the future of America’s ethnicity and the origin and mixing of generations that makes up what America is today. According to Rodriguez, ‘black’, ‘white’, and ‘yellow’ are incomplete or incorrect racial representations. However, ‘brown’ represents the ‘blood that is blended’ (xi), ‘the meeting of the Indian, the African, and the European in colonial America’ (xii). Similar to Takaki, Rodriguez suggests a more inclusive concept of American identity, a concept that takes into account the mixture and multicultural traces of America’s origins. Rather than a debate in regards to the advantages or disadvantages of bilingual education, Rodriguez focuses on the continuous evolution of the English language, its transformation throughout the centuries to incorporate the unique history and experiences of its people. ‘Americans do not speak English […]’, he argues, ‘[…] we speak American’ […] (111), a language that is full of its own dialects, nouns and verbs, proverbs and phrases; a language that has been evolving according to the diversity and mixture of its people. Furthermore, Rodriguez argues that a growing sector of America’s white middle class is not only favourable to bilingual education but are in fact encouraging their own children to be bilingual. In an increasing globalised world, it is only natural that the knowledge of a second language will be rewarded in the job market. As noted by Samuel P. Huntington (2004), immigration from Mexico into the U.S. has its particular characteristics and it is different from past immigration experiences. However, in my point of view, the challenge posed is not how to preserve the traditional concept of American identity, a concept that is inaccurate and based on exclusion. The real challenge is how to strengthen and encourage a new concept, a concept that supports the preservation of different cultures and languages within one nation; a concept that incorporates the mixtures, the blending, and the diversities of a truly multicultural society. References Huntington, Samuel, P. “The Hispanic Challenge.” Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity. New York: Simon & Schuster; 2004. Retrieved from http://www.foreignpolicy.com. Takaki, Ronald. A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. Boston: Little Brown, 1993. Rodriguez, Richard. Brown: The Last Discovery of America. New York: Penguin Putnam, 2002. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mexican Immigration and American Identity

Description of Russian Americans in the North West Region

The first wave began around the 18th century, during which time the Russians who were expanding their territory begun venturing into northwest american areas in search of furs.... Fort Ross was established in 1812 by members of the Russian american company (Marrows 1997).... The immigration by the Russians has brought about many positive and significant contributions both in terms of economy and culture to the North West region of America....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Impact of Immigration on American Society

This paper will discuss the impact of the positive as well as negative impact of the immigration and the controversy revolving around the war brides of the American servicemen.... Impact of Immigration on American Society Impact of Immigration on American Society The Impact of Immigration on American Society Americans, popularly and wholeheartedly celebrate their identity and heritage as a “nation of immigrants” because of their roots in diversity.... Immigration is supported due to the economic growth that it brings about coupled with the establishment of cosmopolitanism which broadens the american society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Redefinition of Japanese American Identity

Name Professor Course Date Redefinition of Japanese american identity Introduction Takaki Ronald's book titled A Different Mirror: History of Multicultural America goes a long way in highlighting the cultural diversity in the country.... resulted in fundamental questions being raised on America's culture and identity.... After the Second World War, and following the treatment of the Japanese Americans during the war, their identity underwent redefinition....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Canadian and American Immigration

The paper "Canadian and american Immigration" states that North America and its two major countries, Canada and the United States, have the highest immigration numbers than any other countries in the world.... immigration to Canada and the United States throughout the proper processes has and continues to be how they open their arms to immigrants worldwide.... Illegal immigration has become a serious problem that raises several ethical, logical, and real concerns that do require serious consideration....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Toward the 21st Century

The paper "Toward the 21st Century" highlights that generally, the central issue was to identify the reasons for immigration by the different populations over the years into the US and compare them with the immigration of the early white settlers in the US.... The aspect of immigration can be seen from this aspect.... o understand migration we must understand the various components involved in migration, including internal migration, external migration, immigration, and both refugees and Internally Displaced Persons....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Mexican Immigrants: Stressors and Problems Faced

One of the main results of mexican immigration is a feeling of insecurity.... According to the Center for immigration Studies in the U.... Additionally and more specifically, the problems encountered by mexican immigrants in the area of communication are discussed.... , the following holds true concerning mexican immigrants, 'Poverty among immigrants in general and mexican immigrants, in particular, is significantly higher than that of natives....
25 Pages (6250 words) Research Proposal

Immigration to the USA

Famously referred in the US to as the american dream, the provision of basic human needs and guarantees for basic rights and freedoms by the government for every american.... The difficult conditions at home for the immigrants make the case for immigration powerful such that not even immigration laws can stand in the quest for a better life across the border....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Immigration

The 1965 immigration and Nationality Act is not biased against a nation (Organization of Americans 15).... This paper ''The immigration'' tells that author examines the contrast between the 1820-1920 periods and the 1960-2010 periods of immigration.... According to the Department of Homeland Security, Yearbook of immigration Statistics, 2008 1820-1920 is the European period's peak to the Americas.... was particularly crucial in influencing immigration....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us