StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What do you see as advantages & disadvantages of being native a speaker and a non-native speaker - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Native speakers of a language enjoy numerous advantages over their non-native counterparts who, subsequently, experience a range of disadvantages due to social exclusion, lack of any intense or ongoing semantic familiarity and the burden of social or ethnic otherness that finds itself replicated in language systems…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
What do you see as advantages & disadvantages of being native a speaker and a non-native speaker
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What do you see as advantages & disadvantages of being native a speaker and a non-native speaker"

What do you see as the advantages & disadvantages of being a native and a non-native speaker? Native speakers of a language enjoy numerous advantages over their non-native counterparts who, subsequently, experience a range of disadvantages due to social exclusion, lack of any intense or ongoing semantic familiarity and the burden of social or ethnic otherness that finds itself replicated in language systems. Advantages also exist for non-native speakers however, as the concept of English as a global language creates a simplified, secondary stream of English language communication. Native and non-native speakers therefore enjoy both positive and negative flow on effects from their degree of expertise or familiarity - and these effects vary as global language systems evolve. LAYERS OF LANGUAGE As the use of English spreads throughout the world and the concept of a global english becomes more viable - a clear delineation emerges between native and non-native speakers of the promoted dominant language. There is a clear linguistic stratification within groups who are speakers of a certain language. Even within groups of native speakers there are cultural, socio-economic and micro-social dialectic particulars creating sub-categories of communication that produce exclusivity within even smaller groups. From the foundation of language basics - commonly learned at infancy by a native group of speakers - a fragmentation occurs whereby verbal and wriiten communication evolves, fragments and channels itself along lines particular to individual experience, social standing and education variables. On a macro1 level there is the English language in its text book form, on a deeper level is the English language among its native speakers within a broader social and cultural context - but even deeper still - and influenced and interdependent upon a multitude of levels in between - is the personalised English language that, honed to a state of flexibility by a lifetime of familiarity and usage - is as reflective of ones personal experiences and as individualised as DNA. EXCLUSION, LITERACY AND SOCIALISATION Language is also malleable and prone to adaptation, change and playful alteration - and it is difficult to pin down, define and - subsequently teach - something which is unpredictable and in a state of constant and often illogical flux. This the basic problem behind attempts to narrow the divide between native and non-native English speakers - and also the core issue when it comes to acknowledging and defining degrees of linguistic disadvantage. It is hard to deny that these micro levels of exclusion - privy only to native speakers - do indeed exist and proliferate throughout society. Olsen (1997, pp. 240-241) examines the way discrimination against non-native speakers can assert itself in the schoolyard: "There are three pieces to the process of Americanization that newcomers to the United States undergo in our high schools: academic marginalization and separation; the requirements to become English-speaking (despite many odds) and to drop ones native language in order to participate in the academic and social life of the high school; and insistent pressures to find and take ones place in the racial hierarchy of the United States." When looking at the specific disadvantages this exclusion sets in motion however - it is important to consider what benefits are open to native speakers who can converse on all levels of micro and macro English communication.Social inclusion has communication as its lifeline and often as its shaping force. Shared experiences can be given a place in the social narrative by way of re-telling or even by the process of expanding upon the core groups common vocabulary. Like twins who create their own language as a type of intimacy, social groups bond over key words, phrases and references that allude to their shared memories.2 These key words, phrases and references are often playful in their use and adaptation of a native tongue and they frequently deviate from basic language structures and rules - but they are no less ladden with meaning and relevance for those that understand them. One of the main ways they foster intimacy - apart from the establishment of an ongoing shared narrative is, conversely, by their ability to exclude others outside of a particular group who do not have access or knowledge of the core groups language. Over time, these references or personalised social cues can evolve into a complex form of communication - and can often cross-reference with popular culture, larger social spheres or geographic determinants.3 Macneil (2005, p.1) speaks of the internal linguistic variables across different soci-economic and geographic locations in parts of the United States: "They know themselves as "Yinzers," from "yinz," the plural of "you," or "you ones." They use "slippy" for "slippery"; "red up" means to "tidy up"; and "anymore" as in "Anymore, theres so many new buildings you cant tell which is which." In downtown Pittsburgh--pronounced "dahntahn" - the question, "Did you eat yet?" sounds like "Jeet jet?" If you havent, the response is, "No, jew? " The problem in the way English is necessarily taught and understood as a secondary language - is that it tends to become essentialised4 - effectively reducing it to a set of linguistic formations and overlooking its inner contradictions, variability and complexity. Those inner attributes - which change all the time and exist in inumerable variations - inform some of the most important communication processes shared among native speakers. According to Macneil (2005, p. 18): "Language change happens and theres nothing you can do about it." The confidence to interact using micro levels of communication, and the familiarity with a native language that allows one to be playful and inventive with meaning and structure - is not something accessible to non-native speakers. Therefore, social exclusion is a key disadvantage for the non-native speaker - who also stands to miss out on of the many connected benefits of inclusion - such as a feeling of emotional connectedness, the ability to utilise networking opportunities and foster personal and business links and the ability to access information that may be beneficial, but which is only shared on the micro level. THE NATIVE TONGUE AND POST-COLONIAL POWER Taken further, social exclusion can become akin to a state of otherness - both on a micro and macro level. According to Tollefson (1991, pp. 207-208): "Language policy is a form of disciplinary power. Its success depends in part upon the ability of the state to structure into the institutions of society the differentiation of individuals into Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“What do you see as advantages & disadvantages of being native a Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1535724-what-do-you-see-as-advantages-disadvantages-of-being-native-a-speaker-and-a-non-native-speaker
(What Do You See As Advantages & Disadvantages of Being Native a Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1535724-what-do-you-see-as-advantages-disadvantages-of-being-native-a-speaker-and-a-non-native-speaker.
“What Do You See As Advantages & Disadvantages of Being Native a Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1535724-what-do-you-see-as-advantages-disadvantages-of-being-native-a-speaker-and-a-non-native-speaker.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What do you see as advantages & disadvantages of being native a speaker and a non-native speaker

Being a Native Speaker and a Non-native Speaker of English

Although the available counts are very divergent, all of them agree on a greater number of non-native than native speakers of English in the world.... English is now the third-most spoken native language worldwide (after Chinese… It has lingua franca status in many parts of the world, due to the military, economic, scientific, political and cultural influence of the British Empire in the 18th and 19th centuries and that of the United States from the 20th Through the global influence of native English speakers in cinema, airlines, broadcasting, science, and the Internet in recent decades, English is now the most widely learned second language in the world....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Evaluation of a planned actiity

The teaching assistant translated it to Urdu, a member of the EAL (English as Additional Language) department translated it to Tamil, and this in turn started a discussion about being ill and going to the doctor.... Page 1, lines 1-2 : If you came up with the title yourself, it should read: Evaluate how the planned activity went and whether the role play supported the reading, writing, speaking and listening abilities of all the pupils including bilingual pupils In a diverse and… This has influenced the interaction of parents towards their children and their perspective towards other people's children, and teachers, doctors and others give advice to But the ideas of some people concerning children growing up in bilingual environments have not in any way benefited these children, and may have an adverse effect on them....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Assessed assignment 2 - Data Analysis Exercise

Lot of – the speaker has used this term to qualify both count as well as non- count nouns.... The speaker says, “there are only one children.... For the native speaker, it is an irregular plural but the speaker has mis-analysed the form, hence his use of one/a is consistent with his treatment of this form as singular.... We can conclude that for speaker A, children is semantically singular but syntactically plural....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Life in Thailand

The writer of this essay " The Life in Thailand" discusses that he loved the national Thai legends, and he dreamt of being like ancient heroes from the stories.... My native country is Thailand, which means “freedom”, and we call our country “Prathet Thai”....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How the Study of Language Can Change Society

I am a regular reader of your column, and I am amazed at the way you give sound advice and back it up with informative nuggets of wisdom.... What should I do?... The author of the currents research paper "How the Study of Language Can Change Society" states that every day, each and every person the world over who lives in the company of other people communicates in one way or another with those whom he comes in contact with....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

My History as a Writer

you see, writing is very much different from talking.... I am not a native English speaker which makes it even more difficult for me to translate my thoughts into words.... Writing a technical paper or an essay for that matter is what you might call an “excruciating experience” for me.... As Jobs had pointed out, we do not have to live with the results of other people's thinking (Young, Jeffrey 2005).... I have learned how to speak the English language while I was a student in Jordan but what I learned in school was not the same as the language used in the streets of the United States....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Main Reasons for English Popularity

nbsp; John Gray argues that “socially legitimated forms of language and high-status foreign languages are seen as a kind of asset, and speakers with the ability to deploy them… cultural or material advantages such as prestige, influence, or employment.... The author of this coursework "Main Reasons for English Popularity " describes English as lingua franca....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Sociolinguistic of an Individual Language Learner

Similarly, in a study conducted by Bell (1984) in Rickford (1999), there are certain speaker characteristics such as class, gender, or age that tends to be differentiated in a speech to addresses those similar characteristics.... Moreover, English is very much part of the home language environment of nearly half of Chinese and Indian students and systematically being used as a resource in mother tongue language classes around Singapore.... In terms of age, for instance, children from families that do not encourage them to take part in adult conversations or those who can only speak when they are spoken to will be unlikely to participate in classroom discussions (Ammon, 2005)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us