StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Successful Policies of Economic Development in Brazil - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Successful Policies of Economic Development in Brazil" focuses on the critical analysis of the economic evolutions of successful economic development in Brazil. The economic strategy arose in relatively underdeveloped countries as a response to global markets…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Successful Policies of Economic Development in Brazil
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Successful Policies of Economic Development in Brazil"

?How successful have development policies been in Latin America? Select one country [Brazil] and assess its economic evolution from Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI) to date. The economic strategy which is known by the name “Import Substitution Industrialization” arose in relatively under-developed countries as a response to global markets. It was clear that many Latin American countries in particular could not keep up with the fluctuations and demands of a free market system. Many of the participants in the world markets possessed vastly superior technologies, infrastructure and buying power due to their more developed status and stronger currencies. This left weaker economies very vulnerable and so their governments stepped in to guide industrialization in ways which assisted in the development of the country as a whole, rather than just successful trade between individual companies and external customers. The focus was on the internal market rather than on the export market, and the aim of this strategy was to reduce reliance on foreign goods and at the same time encourage local manufacturers to supply more and more goods. In this way the state could retain more of the country’s wealth for internal developments and would not have to borrow to obtain currency for international purchases. As one of the larger South American states, Brazil has played an important part in the economic development of this sub-continent. In the period from the middle of the nineteenth century until the Great Depression in 1929-30 the majority of Latin America enjoyed a phase of export-propelled growth. (Hirschman, p. 1968, 3) The combination of reduced buying and selling capacity in industrialized countries and the huge disruption of the Second World War caused great fluctuations in the world markets and this in turn prompted countries like Brazil to focus more on expanding their own internal market. This is where import substitution was devised, as a method of driving forward industrialization while at the same time reducing the country’s need for outside goods and foreign currencies. This government led strategy was applied in Brazil from 1930 until about 1960. (Skikida, 2005, p. 2) Local manufacturers were encouraged to produce products which had previously been acquired by importation. This encouraged innovation, and schemes were set up that allowed foreign companies to invest in Brazil, and transfer technology into that country so that the demand for finished goods could be met. Hirschman notes that countries who come late to industrialization can benefit from the knowledge that other countries have learned before them, for example Britain and other European states, and as a result of this the introduction of new working practices is much smoother. By the early 1960s import substitution industrialization in Brazil was judged to be a considerable success in the short term, but with some rather negative effects in the longer term. (Macario, 1964) One long term effect was that Brazilian industrialists became complacent, and they got used to the lack of competition that ensured their continued success, regardless how efficient they were. There was no external incentive to improve quality or efficiency, and so when Brazil wanted to participate in the world markets to obtain modern goods, it was found that Brazilian products fell far behind those of competitors. There was also very little independent decision making in the industrial sector, since most of the leadership came from government initiatives. When looking at the import substitution period in Brazil from 1930 onwards it is important to understand the significance of political changes which were introduced by the charismatic leader Getulio Vargas. By setting up a Ministry of Labor he managed to get dialogue going between industrialists and government and this eventually cemented his control over all aspects of the economy. (Roett: 2010, p. 38) This central control deepened import substitution policies and allowed various beneficial reforms such as the creation of a new capital city in Brasilia and a national highway system. There were also some negative results such as human rights abuse and periods of very serious corruption and hyperinflation which in turn caused political turmoil. (Roett: 2010, pp. 14-16) The truth is that the authoritarian style of government brought both good and bad results, and unfortunately import substitution does require considerable control mechanisms to ensure that the collective plans are followed through and that resources flow inside the country and not into foreign banks. The geography of Brazil makes industrialization very difficult, since most of the population is located in or near coastal areas, while most of the resources are located inland with few transport links. By paying a lot of attention to road construction Vargas fostered better links and more encouragement for the development of a wider range of resources. Brazil has a huge land territory and many possibilities for exploitation of natural resources. Despite many different ethnic origins through generations of immigration to Brazil, and a dominant culture based on the Portuguese language, a considerable national unity has been achieved, and this is one of the reasons why this economy has seen many periods of extended growth. Some of the reasons for inflation in Brazil in the import substitution phase have been explored by Parkin, who suggests that many of them are structural and typical of most developing countries. (Parkin: 1991, pp. 38-84) At first agriculture was the dominant source of wealth, but as industrialization grew, so this changed and more people were employed in manufacturing. In 1940 about 70% of the population of Brazil were employed in the agricultural sector, but by 1930 this had dropped to only 31% (Cardoso and Helwege, 1995, p. 91). There were also important social consequences of this shift. Many people moved from villages into larger towns and cities. The gradually increasing need for more skilled workers meant that the government allocated more resources to education. With the building of large scale factories, organisations like trade unions developed in the larger companies. These are all positive developments that were helped along by increasing industrialisation. Thanks to its greater size Brazil also managed to make a success of heavy industries like steel production and automobile construction (Cardoso and Helwege:1995, p. 92). A larger population meant that there was a larger internal market for the goods that were produced internally. By subsidizing industry and not subsidizing agriculture the Brazilian government speeded up this aspect of the country’s development. Yet again this has both good and bad consequences. The good consequence is that industry expands faster, and more skilled jobs are produced, but the bad consequence is that government influence ensures that a natural balance between traditional and newer employment types does not develop. Over and under capacity arises, and the government gets locked into a system of subsidies, over capacities and generally poor productivity because of a lack of any competition. After thirty years of import substitution industrialization some of the internal markets for locally produced products became saturated and there was more and more pressure from the people and from manufacturers to free up the economy so that some of the benefits of free trade could be achieved. Distribution of jobs and wealth across the country was uneven, and there were calls for more diversification and more security for workers. Between 1968 and 1974 Brazil experienced a period of strong growth under an authoritarian government with strong links to the military, but this came to an end with the turbulence caused mainly by the oil crises of the mid-1970s. The 1980s are known as the “Lost Decade” in Brazil, in which “growth stagnated while the gap between rich and poor widened. (Amann: 2011, p. 32) At the end of the 1980s a deliberate attempt to open up Brazil to more trading opportunities was begun, in the hope that this would increase productivity growth. According Ferreira and Rossi this strategy worked: “Our data showed that after declining over the 1980s, both output per worker and total factory productivity (TFP) increased after trade liberalization.” (Ferreira and Rossi: 2003, p. 1384) This was observed to vary across different industries, however, and some sub-sectors such as automobiles, computers and freezers retained government subsidies long after other areas. The largest reductions in protection occurred in plastics, clothing, fabric products and footwear. (Ferreira and Rossi: 2003, p. 1388). The article concludes that productivity is stagnant from 1985 until 1900 and then it increases remarkably as a direct result to government policies such as reducing tariffs and eliminating measures such as import quotas and reserved market shares. (Ferreira and Rossi: 2003, p. 1399) These reforms were effective but they did not resolve all of Brazil’s problems since 1998 Brazil had to seek assistance from the IMF. This pattern of boom and bust seems to be characteristic of modern Brazil. The very latest indications are that Brazil has finally managed to gain control of its economy, and the figures from the last eight or nine years shows steady and even accelerating growth against a background of recession in North America and Europe. The currency is stable, and critics point out that modern leaders like Cardoso (1995-2002), Lula (2003-2010) and Rousseff (2011-) have used a more democratic style to introduce a wider dispersal of wealth across all sectors in society. (Amann: 2011, p. 33). Coffee is still one of the main products and this leaves Brazil open to risks due to the possibilities of local natural catastrophes and weather variations, as well as fluctuations in the world price for this and other commodities. The banking system has exercised a positive influence on inflation, with the result that in general Brazil has at last been able to bear the fruits of many decades of social and economic reform, so that in the new millennium it is beginning to take an increasingly confident role in both exporting and importing world class goods. Self-sufficiency in oil and investment in the means to produce it secures a good basis for on-going stability. Amann points out that Brazil has benefited also from the misfortune of more advanced economies, as for example in the wake of the dotcom crashes of the early 2000s: “Brazil, having cemented in place a stable macroeconomic framework and, benefiting from reformed and increasingly open domestic capital markets, received a surge of portfolio inflows.” (Amann: 2011, p. 34) The overall pattern of Brazil’s development in the last 80 years or so has been at times, wildly erratic, with longer periods of stability under various types of proactive government. Relatively poor physical infrastructure and dependence on a few basic commodities for a large volume of economic activity have always been problems in Brazil and they are still probably going to be a threat for Brazil long into the future, but there are signs that at least the political system is more stable, and the regulatory frameworks are beginning to be more effective. The fear that Brazilian industries cannot compete on a fully free market basis appears to be unfounded. Import substitution gave way to a centrally planned economic model and then finally to a much freer market economy. These stages were all necessary stepping stones to a modern, export-focused economy which takes its rightful place on the world stage. There is, however, one very pressing danger which seems to afflict all Latin American economies: the spectre of inflation. In the words of Cardoso and Helwege: “… 100 percent inflation per year is considered low in Latin America … this new breed of inflation runs faster, partly because the modern sector of the economy responds quickly to external shocks and policy errors by shifting assets abroad electronically. The poor are left behind in the dust.” (Cardoso and Helwege: 1995, p. 18) So far there is no sign of immediate returns to catastrophic inflation rates, and is still growing, although the expansion of GDP was slowing slightly from 8.8% in the second quarter of 2010 to only 5.0% in the fourth quarter. (Fick, 2011) It remains to be seen how well Brazil copes with its now greater integration, or perhaps rather reintegration after a spell of inwardness, into world affairs and world markets. There are some major opportunities for Brazil on the horizon like the plans to host the 2014 World Cup and the 2016 Olympics, both of which are a tremendous vote of confidence from outside the country on its ability to provide the finances and the infrastructure for such huge events. Government commitment to this is of course absolutely critical but a big part of the preparation for these events will be a drive to increase the amount of private investment both in the events themselves and in the longer term buildings and transport links that will ultimately benefit the local people. The ability to pull off this major achievement will be the best demonstration of all that Brazil has entered a new phase of stability and steady economic growth. References Amann, E. 2011. A New Brazilian Economic Miracle? CESifo Forum. Available at: http://www.cesifo-group.de/portal/page/portal/DocBase_Content/ZS/ZS-CESifo_Forum/zs-for-2011/zs-for-2011-1/forum1-11-focus5.pdf Baer, W. 2008. The Brazilian Economy: Growth and Development. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner. Ferreira, C. and Rossi, J.L. 2003. New Evidence from Brazil on Trade Liberalization and Productivity Growth. International Economic Review 44 (4), pp. 1383-1405. Cardoso, E.A. and Helwege. 1995. A. Latin America’s Economy: diversity, trends and conflicts. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Fick, J. 2011. As Brazil’s Economy Slows, Landing Concerns Grow. The Wall Street Journal. March 30th. Hirschman, A.O. (1968) The political economy of import-subsitution industrializatio in Latin America. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 82 (1), pp. 1-32. Macario, S. 1964. Protectionism and Industrialization in Latin America. Economic Bulletin for Latin America 9, pp. 61-101. Parkin, V. 1991. Chronic Inflation in an Industrializing Economy: The Brazilian Experience. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Roett, R. 2010. The New Brazil. Washington D.C.: The Brookings Institution. Skikida, C.D. (2005) Brazil: from import substitution to the 21st century. What is left to do? Ibmec MG Working Paper. WP30. Available at: http://www.ceaee.ibmecmg.br/wp/wp30.pdf Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How successful have development policies been in Latin American Select Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410116-how-successful-have-development-policies-been-in
(How Successful Have Development Policies Been in Latin American Select Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410116-how-successful-have-development-policies-been-in.
“How Successful Have Development Policies Been in Latin American Select Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410116-how-successful-have-development-policies-been-in.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Successful Policies of Economic Development in Brazil

The economic growth and financial development relating to brazil

This piece of research paper presents a literature review on the economic growth and financial development in brazil, based on various economic theory and developmental concepts.... 1- 2) This piece of research paper presents a literature review on the economic growth and financial development in brazil, based on various economic theory and developmental concepts.... The macroeconomic concepts regarding Economic growth will be detailed and explained in the paper in order to compare and contrast empirical results and theory in relation to the economic growth in brazil....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Dark Side of Brazils Economic Rise

This essay "Dark Side of brazil's Economic Rise" presents Brasil Foods that has the potential to succeed in its quest to be the first multinational food production company.... First, it studies brazil as a country and the impact of its economy with regards to providing a competitive advantage to its home-bred companies and industries.... There are four broad factors at play that could influence the success or failure of Brasil Foods 2015 vision: the internal and external influences of the company's host country – brazil; the effect of globalization; the strategies, structure, culture, and capabilities of the company itself; and how it shall go about managing the complexity and change that shall arise out of its new international strategy....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

The Geography and Demographics of Brazil

The paper "The Geography and Demographics of brazil" states that brazil has always had a unique sense of identity.... brazil's international identity places it at an advantage; although a former colony, it was distanced from international tensions that had occupied other nations in their search for a unique national identity.... brazil gained independence from the colonizers in 1822, and after that, it gained freedom from a monarchical rule in 1889 through a military overthrow....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Dispensation of Globalization in Brazil

The paper "The Dispensation of Globalization in brazil" discusses that the dispensation of globalization has eased the way that people relate within the global perspective.... Lastly, we intend to survey the business environment in brazil.... Discussion: Brazil's administrative duties are carried out in brazil, where the elected federal officials reside; she is the 6th largest economy after she overdid the UK in 20111 (Lara, 2010, p.... The US had a commendable trade surplus with brazil between the 1990s and 2002 when she recorded a drastic merchandise trade deficit with brazil....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Brazils Post-WWII Trade Policies, Patterns, and Performances

An Evaluation of brazil's Post-WWII Trade Policies, Patterns, and Performances brazil is one of the countries that took part in World War II.... Even though the war had a negative impact on the economies of most of the countries that took part in the war, the opposite happened to brazil.... Instead of experiencing economic downturn, brazil experienced significant economic growth just after the war.... 6) argue that brazil managed to experience growth after the end of world war due to the trade policies that the government initiated just after the war....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Outbreak of AIDS in Brazil

The first case of AIDS in brazil was recorded back in 1982.... Thus they started what it is known as the "health reform movement" in brazil (Camargo, 2005).... n 1983, the first diagnoses of AIDS were made in brazil.... Also in 1986 the VIII National Health Conference accepted the ideas of the health reform movement, which eventually influenced the health-relevant sections of the new Federal Constitution promulgated in 1988 (a watershed in brazil's re-democratization)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Agricultural Trade Liberalization and Brazils Rural Poor

brazil, a Latin American nation has been a Portuguese colony before it gained its independence in 1822 after Pedro Álvares Cabal landed there in 1500.... Taking into consideration market exchange rates, brazil is the tenth largest market and as far as purchasing power is concerned, it is the ninth (CIA, 2007) brazil has a multiethnic social structure with Roman Catholicism as the dominant religion and Portuguese as the main language.... brazil is officially known as the Federative Republic of brazil....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Brazils Rise and Its Effect on the Globe

The USA was the first state to establish a consulate in brazil in 1808.... Brazil's sustainable economic development and regional clout has enabled it to further its ambitions in the world on the diplomatic front.... Brazil's relations with its neighbors have been complicated due to its size, economic development, and increasing power.... This case study "brazil's Rise and Its Effect on the Globe" discusses is based on the effect of brazil's rise and it's affect on the globe with regards to foreign policy and diplomacy....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us