StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
When each of us make a visit to the doctor’s office for an appointment or are rushed to the emergency room for an unexpected illness or injury, we all have a certain understanding that efforts are being made to make certain that we receive the best treatment and our wishes are…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE)"

Privacy and Confidenitality ________ (CASE) By BHS365- Ethics in Health Care ________ Session When each of us make a visit to the doctor’s office for an appointment or are rushed to the emergency room for an unexpected illness or injury, we all have a certain understanding that efforts are being made to make certain that we receive the best treatment and our wishes are being respected. It is the responsibility of healthcare professionals to respect the decisions of patients and keep all information confidential.

But what happens when the actions of the patients create an ethical conundrum for the healthcare professionals. Among the examples offered concerning potentially intoxicated patients and patients that have or are, in fact committing a crime. How do health care professionals find the balance to make decisions that honor, both, patient confidentiality and other ethical obligations like reporting a potential crime. It is, often, not an easy decision to make. Imagine yourself as an E.R. physician and a patient arrives who has, according to his companions, ingested a large quantity of illegal drugs.

He does not wish to be treated, however, his companions feel that he is mentally impaired by his drug use and should be treated regardless. It is absolutely true that while under the influence of intoxicants one may not be capable of the best possible judgment, however, that may not be true in every case. If one is capable of understanding the consequences of his or her decision regarding receiving treatment and the potential outcomes of refusing it then it would be unethical to disregard their personal choice not to receive medical care.

In the case provided the patient was deemed capable of understanding the situation and was allowed to leave without receiving treatment. Ethically, however, if the patient had not been successful in being evaluated as capable of making his own decisions then treatment would and should be administered despite their objections, or at least until they achieve a more competent mental state; for example the effect of the drugs wears off. In the second scenario we are presented with a woman that has admitted to be unable to retrieve a condom filled with an illegal narcotic substance from her vagina.

In this case the ethical decision required by the healthcare professional is not so easy. There is the health of the patient, but the patient’s potential medical condition was caused in the process of committing a crime. In this case the decision that seems to create amiable solution results from treating the patient, without contacting law enforcement, and then if drugs were retrieved they would be turned over to police without involving the patient.(Pauls, McRae, Campbell & Dungey, 2004) It is true there are no laws that require healthcare providers to report every crime, the majority falls under the umbrella of protecting patient confidentiality, however there are a few exceptions.

Healthcare facilities are required to report concerns of child abuse, issues that are of public health concerns, and injuries caused by gunshots.("Medical record privacy," 2012) That said, it is a possibility if healthcare professionals and physicians were more liberal with how often they contacted law enforcement, then individuals in need of treatment who were injured in some sort of illegal behavior may be less likely to seek medical attention. The fear of the negative health repercussions are always outweighed by their fear of the legal ones.

This is a perfect scenario to apply the rule of the Principle of Double Effect. In that the healthcare professionals are attempting to make the best decision to treat or not treat the patient based on the individual patient that has the least foreseeable negative outcomes. (Grosse, 2010)However, when it comes to crimes committed, allowing the perpetrator to leave could be only allowing them to continue to commit the same crime again and possibly commit a new crime later. There are many who feel, today, that some of the confidentiality laws as it related to wrongdoers need a bit of reform.

Meaning that they feel that someone who commits a crime should not be able to avoid police involvement because they received the injuries requiring care during a commission of a crime, or as the result of one. In the end it has been the intention of the medical professions to maintain that level of confidentiality, privacy, and trust between patient and physicians. That has not changed since the formation of the Hippocratic Oath centuries ago.(Grosse, 2010) It has never been the intention of the strict privacy and confidentiality laws to aid those committing illegal acts, but to make certain that all patients are treated equally regardless of who they are and what they may, or may not, have done.

The world of healthcare ethics can be the source of so many excruciatingly ethically dizzying scenarios that test someone understanding of what is right and wrong. It is situations, like those presented in these case studies, where it becomes important to remember the importance of understanding, embracing, and implementing professional ethics over personal ones.ReferencesGrosse, J. R. (2010, December). Patient confidentiality, hipaa, and public health . Retrieved from http://www.lifeissues.

net/writers/gro/gro_90publichealth.htmlMedical record privacy. (2012). Retrieved from http://epic.org/privacy/medical/Pauls, M., McRae, A., Campbell, S., & Dungey, P. (2004). Ethics in the trenches: Part 2. case studies of ethical challenges in emergency medicine. CJEM : Journal of the Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians, 6(5), 363-366.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1612234-provider-patient-relationship-case
(Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1612234-provider-patient-relationship-case.
“Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1612234-provider-patient-relationship-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Provider- Patient Relationship (CASE)

The Impact of Untreated Bipolar Disorder on Relationships

The case study "The Impact of Untreated Bipolar Disorder on Relationships" revolves around Carlos and his frequents bouts at Bipolar which inherently affected his relationship with his loved ones.... He was born in 1959 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and both his parents had been born in Puerto Rico....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

The Difficulties of Complaining

They should be provided with labeled medicines and with chart indicating its dosage and time to take it, so that they won't miss their medicines, in case the attendant is absent.... Mr Kowalski case happens to be a special one due to his disability to move.... onclusionThe above case study addresses only a specific type of complaint.... It refers to the relationship process between a guest and a host, and it also refers to the act or practice of being hospitable, that is, the reception and entertainment of guests, visitors, or strangers, with liberality and goodwill....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Theory Application and Evaluation

First of all, the nurse needs to develop a trusting relationship with her.... A trusting relationship will help establish Jimmy's faith in the system and create hope in her mind.... This paper tells that Jimmy is a 35-year old AIDS patient and needs a palliative care.... (Watson, 2007)A nursing person with an altruistic attitude is very much required while providing care to the patient such as Jimmy who is not only suffering from the intense pain due to Kaposi Sarcoma lesion in her leg but also suffering from pneumocystis pneumonia-causing her a lot of distress....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Law and Practise Surrounding the Obligation of Confidentiality Owed by a GP to his Patient

First, a bona-fide doctor-patient relationship must exist and that the information learned by the GP should arise from that doctor-patient relationship (Medical Protection Society (Spring 2006).... These two principles are very important to preserve the good relationship between the GP and the patient.... This paper "Law and Practise Surrounding the Obligation of Confidentiality Owed by a GP to his patient" discusses both an ethical and legal issue....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Business Analysis of St Anns Hospice

The above target does not affect the quality of the services provided to the patients/ individuals who need specific care services; in fact, the care provided by the staff of the hospice is of high quality – as possible; the control over the time required for the completion of each program – referring to the care services provided to each individual/ patient by the staff of the hospice – is important for increasing the number of people treated by the hospice's staff, i....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Patient With Adult-Onset Diabetes

The paper "The patient With Adult-Onset Diabetes" describes that possible complications and effects of non-compliance and intervention options that can be taken by our patient's doctor, we can see that at the end of the day, it is still up to our patient to follow his regimen.... hellip; An article called “DIABETICS & NON-COMPLIANCE”, effects that can result from a patient's non-compliance can include “complications that affect the eyes, kidneys, heart, nerves, feet and more” and over time, constant non-compliance can result in “permanent damage of these areas as well as stroke, heart disease and blindness....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Coroners Reporting on the Mental Care Continuity and Assessment

nbsp; In the case of Liam John Wright, continuity would have been greatly enhanced if in any case there was a specific healthcare professional that was monitoring his condition right from the first day when it was noticed that he was having some symptoms of mental problems (Bland, Renouf &Tullgren 2009, p.... n the case of Charlie, it can also be observed that there was a lot of changing of professionals that were held with the responsibility of taking care of Charlie while he wants to undergo treatment at ITO....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Current Issues in Social Media

… The paper "Current Issues in Social Media " is an excellent example of a case study on information technology.... The paper "Current Issues in Social Media " is an excellent example of a case study on information technology.... Undeniably, social media has essentially changed the healthcare industry's communications relationship.... The surfacing of social media communications platforms that permit sincere, as well as open conversation, offers affluence of opportunities for the health industry to build on a positive patient attitude and develop a supportive community that is trusted to dynamically connect with (Azizi, 2013)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us