StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Changes Brought with Crusades - Essay Example

Summary
The paper "Changes Brought with Crusades" highlights that there are a number of motivations for the Crusades during the Twelfth Century, from religious inclinations to hopes of adventure fueled by medieval romances, as well as the factor of personal gain…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Changes Brought with Crusades
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Changes Brought with Crusades"

What Were the Motives of Crusaders in the Period up to 1204 and how much did they Change? The motivation behind movements such as the crusades, whichwere not only popular amongst the elite who went to fight, but also among the general population, is exceedingly difficult to define. In a mass movement such as this, individuals may have a range of different motivations which are not universal, while there may be underlying causes which cannot be seen across the centuries. The historian of the crusades must attempt to analyze the testimony, look at economic and social factors, and read motivation into the actions of those who traveled to the Holy Land to fight. By the time of the First Crusades, the Holy Lands of Jerusalem, Palestine, and the pilgrimage routes connecting these places to Europe, were under threat from an organized and ambitious Ottoman Empire. The Moslems themselves kept the routes open to Christians, and the Byzantine Empire safe, until 1071, when Seljuk Turks took the lands, and persecuted Christians on the way. Lost land, religious conflict, and internal pressures were the background to Western Europe’s initiation of the Crusades. R.W. Southern notes that “The worsening position of the Eastern Empire, and the genuine desire of some to save it: the even more potent though secret desire of others to profit by its disintegration; the dim realization that Islam constituted a…threat to Christendom…some hoped to be saved by going; others didn’t care if they were damned so long as they found new fields for profit and adventure. There was something in the Crusades to appeal to everyone.” (Southern, 56) The crusades were, as Riley-Smith states “A holy war fought against those perceived to be external or internal foes of Christendom for the recovery of Christian property or in defence of the church or Christian people” (Riley-Smith, 1987, xxviii). This was certainly the overt motivation for the first Crusade, as initiated by Pope Urban II in November of 1095. This Crusade had a peculiar beginning, and Riley-Smith has made extensive note of this: “Few nobles turned up, and the theatre must have been risky…even so, his appeal for knights to liberate Jerusalem struck a chord in western society” (Riley Smith, 1995). Urban openly declared “’Dieu le veult’ – ‘God wills it!’” (Bishop, 105); for many hearing the religious leader of the Western World declaring God’s Will, the Crusades must have seemed to be a religious duty. In considering why this speech made such an impression, it should not be forgotten that the majority of Western Europe was, by this time, Christian in name at the very least. Europeans had been making the arduous pilgrimage to Jerusalem for decades, and in some ways the early Crusades might be considered another form of pilgrimage. Personal penance and justification by faith were still quite strong issues of faith, and would remain so until at least the mid-fourteenth century (Flagellants during the Black Death being one example of this). Being a Crusader, not only fighting for Christ but also traveling to the Holy Land to do so, was therefore a religious duty, atonement for sin, and a Holy Quest, similar to that being written about in Early Medieval romances. In fact, it seems as though Urban did not intend to have such a dramatic effect upon the nobles of Europe: the impression is that “The pop was taken aback by the success of his proposal. No plan had been made for the prosecution of the crusade” (Bishop, 106). The organization of the First Crusade was rather like a mopping-up exercise, after the disastrous People’s Crusade in 1096. Poor people such as this marched under their own steam to free Jerusalem, and rather than the idealism of the nobility, their motivations appear to be genuine religious concern for the Holy Land. It should be clear, therefore, that the overt motivation, religion, was also an emotional force for many of the participants in the first Crusades, Kings and princes, such as Richard I of England, who were not struggling to maintain a fief, were probably motivated to a greater degree by religion; the percentage of religious motivation may fall as one progresses down the ranks. A secondary aspect of this religious motivation should be acknowledged, that: “All the Crusades have to be considered in the context of Rome’s Catholic but fruitless ambition to subjugate…the Eastern Church to the Papacy” (Heer, 126). The Byzantine Church was a source of opposition to the Catholic Christian faith, and this may be one of the reasons why those living in the East, such as Raymond of Antioch, where depicted as libidinous and pleasure-loving. The intention of the Church to gain dominance over the East, while a strong motivation for Urban and later Popes, may not have been a strong motivation for those actually making the pilgrimages, who relied upon the Eastern Empire for protection during the journey. It should not be forgotten, however, that Urban’s speech did not merely concentrate upon the religious aspects of the crusade. It is clear from economic and historical studies that the European nobles were running out of land and income: in other words, they were having too many sons who survived to adulthood. Urban’s speech emphasized that France (where he was giving the speech) was overcrowded: “It could barely support its sons…a poor crusader might find himself tempted by a fief of holy land: and if he should fall, he was assured, by papal promise, of a seat in heaven” (Bishop, 105). Poor knights, looking for an easy land-grab, may have been more common as the Crusades progressed. Certainly, there is little sign of religious fervor in the Crusade of Louis VII of France: the King even took along his Wife and her large entourage. Camp followers were inevitable, but bringing along a Queen and her baggage, considering that they were invading and involved in hand to hand combat, seems very foolish; the only conclusion can be that Louis perceived his Crusade as a pilgrimage, or even a Grand Tour, rather than an invasion. It should also be noted that Louis’ Crusade, and its failure, lead to the fall of Jerusalem in 1187 to Turkish forces and increasing Moslem strength throughout the Holy Land. As well as religion and money, a motivating factor in the later Crusades of the Twelfth Century was adventure. This is a period of high-romance (Troubadours in Southern France, and the beginnings of the convention known as Courtly Love), and the children of Nobles would have been raised on Romantic Literature such as Arthurian romances, and legends like Troilus and Cressida, which date from this period. The Bible played a part in this, and the mystical aspects of Western Christianity may have been linked to the Crusades, providing a spiritual and romantic motivation for Crusaders. As has been shown, there are a number of motivations for the Crusades during the Twelfth Century, from religious inclinations to hopes of adventure fueled by medieval romances. The Religious element seems strongest during the First Crusade, when it affected not only Nobles (who were invited to witness Urban’s Speech but were not interested enough to turn up), but also the general population. This ideal in the early years does seem to be based upon religious inclination, rather than Southern’s “Men who were accustomed to the obligations occurred by holding land in return for military service…imaging themselves the feudatories of an injured God, seeking in a most literal way to exchange by military service a life tenancy on earth for a perpetual inheritance in heaven” (Southern, 57). This could be a motivation for the Second and Third Crusades, which were the first to induce Kings and Princes to actually travel to the Holy Land, rather than provide men and money. The Second Crusade resembles a romantic interlude; the princes traveling with their entourage as though there was nothing to fear. The later Crusade, which also bears romantic motivation, appears to be a combination of religious, feudal, and romantic motivations. Bibliography Bishop, Morris (1983) The Pelican Book of the Middle Ages Pelican, New York Heer, Friedrich (1974) The Medieval World: Europe From 1100 to 1350 Cardinal, London Riley-Smith, Jonathan (1987) The Crusades: A short history Yale University Press Riley-Smith, Jonathan (1995) “Religious Warriors. Reinterpreting the Crusades” The Economist, 23 Dec 1995 Southern, R.W.(1962) The Making of the Middle Ages Arrow Books, London. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Changes Brought with Crusades

The first crusade 1096-1109

This essay analyzes crusades, that were the religious wars that were undertaken by Western European Christians against Middle East Muslims.... The crusades were nine in number and they mainly intended to rescue the Holy Land (Jerusalem) and other Christian territories.... The First Crusade is considered by many as the most successful of all the nine crusades....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Internal weaknesses that impacted the Islamic Societies during the Crudades and Mongol Wars

Islamic Societies during the crusades and Mongol Wars ... he crusades comprised of military units from the Roman Catholics all over the Western Europe, under no unified command.... The major series of crusades took place between 1095 and 1291.... crusades were a sequence of some religious expeditionary wars that were blessed by the Catholic Church's pope with a stated goal, which was to restore Christian access to holy places in the neighborhood of Jerusalem City....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Crusaders and the Church

The battles are about the historical and moral significance of the crusades.... For many knights, especially the participants of the first crusades, the march was a form of religious initiation and repentance performed with prayers, fasts, and vows.... The difference is striking: one group of people, the clergy, was legally prohibited to take part in the crusades; the spiritual leaders were against the murders or at least saw the controversy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Bequest and Exemplification of Christian Worldview

crusades describe a series of expeditions from western Europe to the East Mediterranean.... The crusades aim to recover the holy lands from Islam invasion so that they can be retained in Christian hands due to their high regard for Jerusalem.... Their other aim was to reduce the influence of the Ottoman empire through all means thereby the accomplices of the crusades were granted the status of martyr in the event of their death during the crusades....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Motivation for Crusades

The motivation behind movements such as the crusades, which were not only popular amongst the elite who went to fight, but also among the general population, is exceedingly difficult to define.... The historian of the crusades must attempt to analyze the testimony, look at economic and social factors, and read motivation into the actions of those who traveled to the Holy Land to fight. ... y the time of the First crusades, the Holy Lands of Jerusalem, Palestine, and the pilgrimage routes connecting these places to Europe, were under threat from an organized and ambitious Ottoman Empire....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Changing Nature of the Crusades between 1095 and 1204

The paper "The Changing Nature of the crusades between 1095 and 1204" highlights that the crusades viewed ''in the light of their original purpose, the crusades were failures.... The crusades, which meant fighting for the defense of Christians, came to be considered a work of piety.... '1The crusades took on new meaning later on.... The Church moved away from the sole aim of the crusades which was the liberation of the Holy Land from the invasion of the Turks and it began using the crusades to serve the church's own interest....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Christians and Jews During the Crusades

This essay "Christians and Jews During the crusades" compares the religious traditions of Christians and Jews during the time of the crusades.... There is some indication that during the crusades, the Jewish communities along the Rhineland were relieved that the Christian mobs had gone to the Holy Land....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

History of the Crusades

The paper "History of the crusades" highlights that the crusades were wars that were waged in an extremely violent fashion.... The term 'crusades' describes military expeditions which were supposed to be religiously inspired and considered pilgrimages.... The original crusades in the Levant was an outgrowth of the revival of religious feeling and missionary zeal that had begun in Europe in the tenth century.... Considered as 'Holy Wars' towards Christ's Sepulchre, the crusades were inspired by the priestly power that represented to the people the other world of divinity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us