StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The goal of the essay "Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness" is to further identify Said's two visions that he seems to think are present in this short novel and to discuss the culture and imperialism that he claims exist in Conrad's piece…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Saids Critique of Conrads Heart of Darkness
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness"

Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness In this critique of a critique, I will examine Edward Said's opinion of Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness. It is through the author's essay, Two Visions in 'Heart of Darkness' that I can analyze his thoughts and opinions on the short novel and develop my own thoughts about this short work. The goal of this essay is to further identify Said's two visions that he seems to think are present in this short novel and to discuss the culture and imperalism that he claims exist in Conrad's piece. The initial paragraph in Said's critique is, to be frankly put, garbage. Let's just get that opinion of mine out of the way that a series of run on sentences with big words do not tell me anything about what he thinks about the essay at the topic of discussion. I realize this is a critique of where the author's position stands and whether or not I agree with it, but he has it so sprinkled with fancy and eloquent words that are intended to make him sound smart that it is difficult to determine what in the world he is trying to convey in regards to the essay. That being said, I will further attempt to summarize his critique. I think it is a good point that Said evaluated Marlow's characterization and dramatization of who Marlow is as a narrator in the original Conrad essay. It helps to make readers aware of who Marlow is and it symbolizes also who Conrad was as some of Marlow's characteristics and life experiences are representative of Conrad himself as a person who fell victim to contemporary society at the time which turned him then into also a victim of imperialism. It also makes quite obvious that it was difficult to escape the force of that imperialism. He had no choice. I think that Said is correct in his combination of identifying that Marlow is a direct representation of Conrad but in character form. The story would tell of the issues of the culture at the time and a response to it as a person living in that society at the time. The Marlow character may have owned up to the changes that he had to fall in line with in society, culture and imperialism, while Conrad, who was conflicted about doing so, did not have to take direct responsibility for his actions, but instead represented his life through that of a fictional character. I really like how the author addressed this because Conrad is so self-conscious about the situation. Said identified, as previously stated, two visions in the post-colonial realm of society in Conrad's essay when Africa was divided into European colonies. Said states that it seems as though Conrad could not envision any other way of life, regardless of where you are located. I also agree with Said that Conrad wrote as though the way of the Europeans was the only way that people all around the world also lived. Said implies that Conrad was not informed thinking that the world he saw before him may be the only way that there was to live, when in fact he fails to identify that the other ways of the world would be different than he assumes it would be. Said also seems to imply that Conrad really did not necessarily recognize all aspects of the world and take into account the future of the world beyond what the current status was in society. I think also at times that Said overstepped his boundaries of his own intelligence as he oftentimes went into examples that did not necessarily relate directly to Conrad's own narration. He then, however, draws himself back to the point of the issue at hand to identify the culture and aesthetics that were present in Conrad's essay. Said just always seems to jump off on tangents. I think that regardless of who anyone is, they all offer their own points of view on a topic, regardless of whether it is academic, journalistic or even just someone bantering about something that they do not really know anything about. Though I think that Said is a very intelligent person, I think he is simply bantering about something that he does not know that much about. I thought it was a terrible critique and at times either just rambled on, went in a completely different direction or was just plain pointless. I did agree with some of the things that he said in his critique as I think he was right on that Conrad did not want to take responsibility for how things were going on in his world and how he had to fall into stride with it. However, he instead used a character to metaphorically encompass the ways of the world. I think that Said finally came back into the whole theme of the critique when he finally started to step off his soap box and started to summarize a bit about Heart of Darkness. Anyone who had never read this essay would have no idea what in the world he was talking about just based off his critique. You would have to read both essays to even try to figure out what the main point of Said's essay was even about. Never once does he make a really good example of how things really were in the essay or really the points Conrad tried to make. Said instead seemed to use it as a political soapbox to assume Conrad's stance and maybe even perhaps to step on his own. Conclusively, I do not either agree or disagree with Said's theory and criticism behind Conrad's essay. I think it was designed to reach out to the British literature scholars. As an average student, I did not derive very much useful information at all from this essay and instead am just as puzzled about what the point of it was before I even read it. Not saying that it was not well written, it just was not written with a person without a background in British Literature and European and African historical knowledge even in mind. Works Cited Said, Edward. Two Visions in 'Heart of Darkness.' Culture and Imperialism, 1993. pp. 22-31. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1585435-critical-essay
(Said's Critique of Conrad'S Heart of Darkness Essay - 1)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1585435-critical-essay.
“Said's Critique of Conrad'S Heart of Darkness Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1585435-critical-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Said's Critique of Conrad's Heart of Darkness

Images of light and dark in Joseph Conrads Heart of Darkness and James Joyces Araby

These are the images that are evoked in conrad's heart of darkness.... Imagery of light and dark play important roles in both the writing of Joseph Conrad's in heart of darkness and James Joyce's in Araby.... Imagery of light and dark play important roles in both the writing of Joseph Conrad's in heart of darkness and James Joyce's in Araby.... Joyce uses the imagery of darkness through a number of different devices in order to evoke a state of...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Novella Heart of Darkness

Subject heart of darkness The novella heart of darkness has always raised controversy for the interesting way Joseph Conrad has written it.... At this point the fact to be admitted is that when Joseph Conrad wrote heart of darkness, and even at the time presented in the story, the British colonial empire was at its zenith.... While Kurtz admitted the rules of the wild, Marlow is not ready to descend into that darkness.... hellip; Thus, it seems that Joseph conrad's work gives the readers a chance to identify how European ideals are darker than the African ones as the work is, in some way, a comparison of both....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Conrads Heart of Darkness and Baldwins Sonnys Blues

conrad's heart of darkness and Baldwin's Sonny's Blues are considered great pieces of literature and this is due in no small part to the narrative style used in the works.... In both of the writings, the little known narrator, who is for the most part unsure of himself, shows… Sonny and Kurtz....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analysis of Heart of Darkness

Conrad himself commanded a steamship in the Belgian Congo in the year 1890, and this experience became the foundation for “heart of darkness”(http://www.... It is the metaphoric meaning of darkness that is more prevalent throughout the novel.... Conrad suggests that such a cloak of darkness can camouflage savage acts that would be impossible to contemplate in European civilization.... om/ darkness is the strongest… It is perceived as well as used to symbolize something....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Chinua Achebe's response to Conrad's Heart of Darkness novel

The paradox of the critique presented by Achebe upon ‘heart of darkness' and in turn Conrad himself, that he is using the same premise to set up his case, as the one which he attempts to ridicule.... He is Chinua Achebe on ‘heart of darkness' The paradox of the critique presented by Achebe upon ‘heart of darkness' and in turn Conrad himself, that he isusing the same premise to set up his case, as the one which he attempts to ridicule.... Hence, the claim made by Achebe can be rendered as void; his passion with his creed are understandable (being a Nigerian himself), but the ‘heart of darkness' should be taken in the spirit of literary delight, rather than political turmoil....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's Heart of Darkness by Chinua Achebe

The paper “An Image of Africa” looks at Conrad's novel “The heart of darkness”, which completely dehumanizes Africans and treats them as brutes, savages, and mere props to give his novel a convincing touch in complete disregard of the sublime values an author of his stature is supposed to espouse.... Achebe is specially disturbed by the fact that Conrad's novel “The heart of darkness” completely dehumanizes Africans and treats them as brutes, savages and mere props to give his novel a convincing touch in complete disregard of the sublime and enlightened values an author of his stature is supposed to espouse....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Heart of Darkness

Joseph Conrad, who in the book of ‘heart of darkness appears to be impersonating himself to Marlow, seeks to establish the various atrocities that the Europeans committed to the native Africans in the pre-colonial and colonial period.... The heart of darkness elaborates that the Europeans progressed The script further entails a summary of the ‘heart of darkness' and the implied atrocities that depict the European colonialists as dark hearted, to the extent that they suffice the cultural and societal norms of the African Congo community....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Critique of Heart of Darkness

He also believes that missionary view of Africa was biased because they were traveling to Africa for the… At this particle point I do agree with Fothergill, most of the people who first came to Africa had preset mind that Africa was uncivilized continent “just as though I had got a heavenly mission to civilize you” (Conrad Fothergill Critique on heart of darkness According to Fothergill around 19th Century, there were a biased African assumption that affected all literary works published around that time including the one by Conrad....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us