StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Criticism of Porter's Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View of Strategic Management - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the literature of strategic management one of the most important topics is the way in which firms attain their competitive advantage and maintains them. The two major concepts that have been developed regarding the way in which this can be achieved are commonly referred as…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Criticism of Porters Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View of Strategic Management
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criticism of Porter's Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View of Strategic Management"

The paper “Porter’s Five Forces and Resource-Based View of Strategic Management" is a meaty example of a term paper on management. In the literature of strategic management, one of the most important topics is the way in which firms attain their competitive advantage and maintains them. The two major concepts are commonly referred to as the resource-based view and Porter’s five forces. Porter’s five forces model is also referred to as the positioning school (Stonehouse and Snowdon, 2007).

However, Porter’s models of competitive forces have been subject to major criticism. From an economic point of view, it has been observed by Hax and Wilde (2002) that the model of Porter assumes a perfectly competitive market which is a utopian concept. It has also been observed that Porter’s model can at best be used to analyze simple market structure because as the industry structure becomes complex with multiple interrelations then the model is not very suitable (Hax and Wilde, 2002).

It has also been argued that the model assumes too static market conditions which may be impractical (Berg-Marketing, n.d.). For instance, Pepsi’s competitive strategies are actually determined by the strategies of Coca-Cola rather than world market for soft drinks. This shows that the essence of strategic competition is actually derived from the interaction between the players (Schmidt, 2010). Porter had also pointed out that the five forces approach uses a zero-sum game framework where one firm can succeed at the cost of others.

This is not always true in real like as it has been observed that Toyota and Honda work very closely with its suppliers to ensure the availability of parts (Srivastava and Verma, 2012). Again in a recent empirical study conducted it has been observed that according to Porter’s five forces the IT industry in India should have been unattractive yet, in reality, this could not be confirmed given the robust performance of this industry (Krishnamurthy, 2010 ). The Resource-Based View is an alternative view that tries to overcome the limitations of Porter’s five forces model.

The Resource based view of a firm focuses on the internal competencies of the firm that determines the key competencies of the firms. The resource based view emphasizes that the firm derives its competitive advantage and performance from the resources it owns. RBV has also been assumed to provide an efficiency-based explanation for determining the differences in the performance of firms. RBV has been able to take into consideration the internal resources which were ignored by Porter. RBV actually tries to show that the internal capabilities of the firm are actually important in determining the strategic choices taken up by the firm in its external environment.

For instance, the resources and the capabilities of companies like Apple and Toyota have allowed them to come up with products like i-pod and hybrid cars which have created new markets and added value to the customers. Toyota’s capability like using efficient production techniques, excellent control over the inbound logistics backed by proper measures of marketing and advertising provides the firm with a competitive advantage which allows it to earn maximum revenue in the automobile industry (Henry, 2011).

According to Porter, it is the industry structure within which the firms operate that determines the level of profit. However, in real life, it has been observed that the profitability of Tesco and Sainsbury, both of which operates in the food retail market of U.K. have different levels of profitability (though according to the model of Porter they should have had similar levels of profitability) (Henry, 2011).  Though this theory tries to explain the source of competitive advantage yet it is not free from criticism.

Criticisms about this theory pertain to the unit of analysis, neglecting environment and behavioral and assumptions of the inimitable nature of resources. These criticisms restrict the credibility of this theory limiting its explanatory power. RBV has also been criticized on the grounds of being an excessive inside-out view. Porter had argued that the resource based view cannot be considered as an alternative view that helps in determining strategy. Priem and Butler (2001) had argued that the RBV is circular in nature which makes the outcomes of the model inevitable (Priem and Butler, 2001).

Foss (1998) argues that the legitimacy of the resource based view is only valid if the relevant resources are properly defined and free-standing (Foss, 1998). Barney (1991) had argued that in order for a firm to maintain a competitive advantage the resources must be valuable, rare, inimitable, and substitutable (Barney, 1991). Porter (1991) had argued that resources cannot be rare by themselves and technology, the behavior of the buyer and can change the nature of the resources (Porter, 1991).

Though the model developed by Barney has been widely accepted in strategic literature yet only a few types of research have been done to establish the empirical validity of the statement. A recent study conducted by Talaja (2012) on Croatian firms had confirmed that the hypothesis predicted by the theory is valid (Talaja, 2012). However, more research empirical needs to be conducted before accepting this approach.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Criticism of Porter's Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View Term Paper, n.d.)
Criticism of Porter's Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/management/1825769-answering-an-exam-question-on-strategic-management
(Criticism of Porter'S Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View Term Paper)
Criticism of Porter'S Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/management/1825769-answering-an-exam-question-on-strategic-management.
“Criticism of Porter'S Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/management/1825769-answering-an-exam-question-on-strategic-management.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criticism of Porter's Competitive Forces Model and Resource-Based View of Strategic Management

Michael Porters Contribution to the Field of Strategic Management

14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Porters Diamond Model

Innovativeness of the nation is also reflected from the fact that successful management techniques like Kaizen which have become the standards for present day business organizations (Ankli, n.... hellip; 1 Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Porter's Diamond model 4 Factor Conditions 5 Demand Conditions 6 Firm Structure, Strategy and Rivalry 7 Related and Supporting Industries 8 The Role of Chance 10 Role of State 11 Conclusions 12 References 14 Bibliography 15 Introduction Competition among nations is an age old traditions that has been in place since the early Greeks and Romans....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Porters Model of National Competitive Advantage

Porter used strategic management theories and analyzed them with international trade and economy.... This essay explores what the strengths and limitations of porter's model of national competitive advantage are in explaining the comparative nature and achievements of national business systems.... The nation acts as a 'home base' for the firms, this home base helps in developing the firm's strategy, culture, character of its management, the availability and quality of resources, technology and helps it in establishing prior to its expansion internationally as the firms grow domestically before they plan their expansion internationally....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Porter's Competitive Forces Model-Information Systems

This paper highlights porter's competitive forces model-information systems.... Thus the competitive forces model helps one to understand the different strategies that the firm can take to counter the competition.... Porter's Five forces model is considered as the best model that can be applied in understanding the competitive position of a business in regard to its external business environment.... Thus the Porter's Five forces model effectively presents the situational analysis of a company's external environment based on which the firm is required to develop its potential strategies required for market growth and business development....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Critical Analysis of Strategic Approaches

Critical Analysis of strategic Approaches 1.... The model enables businesses generating ideas of minimizing competition as much as possible, among them being the justification of strategic alliances and partnerships, continued innovativeness, commitment to quality, employment of information systems to analyze market moves and define desirable market structure (Middleton 2003, p16).... The applicability of porter's forces in many industries is important to managers who rely on measurable outcomes to inform workable and appropriate business strategy....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Porter's model of national competitive

This has opened up debate among economists and scholars based on the management theories.... However, the model has failed to capture support from the economic school of thought and relies on management theories.... This paper explains theories underlying the economic and management schools of thought.... The first section gives an overview of trade theory that gives reasons for differences between economists and management specialists on international competitiveness of countries....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Structure and Performance in a Transition Economy

Organizations with hybrid strategies are much less exposed to strategic uncertainty than organizations with pure strategies.... Porters point out that MBV has a significant impact on the strategic business unit level.... Meanwhile, a market-based view on the work of Michael porter will be discussed and it assumes that profitability is established mainly by the structure of the industry in which the company operates.... He argues that this approach provides an efficient model of evaluating the nature of competition within an industry....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Key Elements of Performance Management System of FedEx Corporation

A… r of strategic management tools are used for strategic analysis of the internal and external business environment, on the basis of which the strategies are formulated and implemented in response to the situation.... A strategy provides a direction to the organization and a roadmap The purpose of this report is to conduct a strategic audit of a real-life organization and on the basis of strategic issues being faced by the organization, the goals, actions and key elements of performance management system to develop strategy are discussed in this organizational context....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us