StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why Do Large Companies Like IBM Find It Difficult to Create New Businesses - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper titled "Why Do Large Companies Like IBM Find It Difficult to Create New Businesses" evaluates the “horizons of growth” model. The author of the paper also identifies the distinguishing features of emerging, H3 businesses…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Why Do Large Companies Like IBM Find It Difficult to Create New Businesses
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why Do Large Companies Like IBM Find It Difficult to Create New Businesses"

Q why do large companies like IBM find it so difficult to create new businesses? What are the primary barriers to success? Large organizations areoften victim of their own glory and over the period of time develop as complacent organizations. The inability to clearly visualize the future and strategic orientation of the external world make it more difficult for them to expand or evolve into new arenas with better prospects. The change that took place within the personal computer industry especially during 1990s clearly indicated a marked shift towards more open business models where small and more agile competitors were more successfully than the larger and more dominant organizations like IBM. The success of Dell over IBM can easily be attributed to the fact that Dell attempted to exploit a market niche which was hardly considered as future market prospect by the IBM. As mentioned in the case study that the mangers at IBM often considered new opportunities for innovation as a distraction from their core business activities thus limiting themselves to only those opportunities which corroborated their existing strengths. Inability of the senior management to reward and look for new and strategic opportunities and rather reward short term results. Though, short term results play a critical role in keeping the organization is momentum however, it is really critical that the organization and its management must develop the skills and aptitude to reward the long term strategic building of the business. Large organizations such as IBM therefore lack the ability to focus on thinking beyond what they are good at and focus more on achieving the near term results. Large organizations are also often pre-occupied with their existing markets and demand patterns observed in existing markets may serve as a satisfying factor for them. A higher and consistent demand from existing markets therefore is one of the reasons why large organizations fail to create new businesses because short terms strategic business targets are often achieved from existing markets rather. This however, also indicates that the large organizations often become complacent and stop looking for new opportunities. It is also important to note that the strategic financial objectives of the firm may be different as compared to growing organizations. Since large organizations often pass through their maturity stage therefore they focus on achieving sustainable profit targets rather than taking actions to drive higher P/E values. Since cash flow patterns are more predictable for mature organizations therefore the need to drive higher value by creating new opportunities. Ability to take risks is another important factor which frightens most of the organizations to look for new markets and businesses. The more conservative the management approach is more difficult it would be to invest in risky and new businesses. Large organizations often focus on their existing businesses offering stable returns rather than forecasting new opportunities to invest into new businesses. This inability also therefore restricts them to look for more risky adventures which can otherwise provide higher returns and offer new opportunities to diversify. Q#2 What is your evaluation of the “horizons of growth” model? What are the distinguishing features of emerging, H3 businesses? The development of horizons of growth model took place in the midst of serious strategic disasters where large organizations failed to enjoy the benefits perceived to be obtained from mergers and acquisitions. The so called consolidation myth did not seem to have worked for most of the companies and it was argued that while looking for new business approaches and opportunities, it is also critical that the businesses must keep their eye on consolidating their existing core competencies. The alternative to deal with such situation was presented in the form of Horizons of growth model which presented the idea of the three horizons of growth by outlining and indicating the three distinctive growth phases or horizons which an organization need to account for. The first horizon was to consolidate on the existing core competencies of the firm so that the firm continues to enjoy its traditional competitive advantage. In the next horizon stage is the stage where organization actually starts building the emerging businesses which can actually support the medium term profitability and growth objectives of the firm. Last horizon is based on the creation of viable options to look for and generate long term prospects therefore at this horizon; organizations often tend to look for visionary leadership to conceive ideas which can be materialized in future. The horizons of growth model may be a relatively more predictable model to measure and predict the future growth prospects. It is however, also important to note that organizations have to pursue all three horizons together in order to achieve the objectives and as such management shall be more pro-active in visionary. The most distinguishing factor of H3 businesses is the fact that they reflect the long term future opportunities for the firm which is considered as necessary to ensure the long term future of the firm. Since, H3 businesses are mostly less developed therefore a more creative and visionary leadership and management is required to materialize these businesses into reality. Q#3 The evolution of the EBOs at IBM began in two distinctive phases- i.e. one under the era of Thompson and second and most important phase was that of the corporate strategy era. At the time of Thompson, the evolution started slowly and more traditional manner as he was considered as one of the most respected personalities at IBM. First of all, his elevation to the post of vice president was a strong motivational signal for most of the managers working on the different EBO projects therefore there was a wide ranging acceptability of the change without any significant resistance to change. The beginning of Thompson era saw the consolidation of responsibility among the people working on EBOs as by doing so Thompson insured that the roles are clearly defined at the beginning so that everyone must have a very clear idea of what is expected from each other. This therefore allowed IBM to basically focus on the main strategic objective. These EBOs in this era started to evolve in more solid footing as Thompson was personally involved in the processing of reviewing the progress made and contemplated on the changes if required. These reviews however, were not considered as the traditional reviews at the IBM but were mainly focused on consultation and development of new ideas for making the process of EBOs more strategic and robust in nature. It is also important to understand that these reviews provided a very important insight directly to the top management of the firm on possible qualitative weaknesses which IBM was witnessing as in the past qualitative aspects of analyzing business opportunities were completely ignored. IBM’s traditional method for analyzing the new opportunities was largely based on evaluating the hard core financial data therefore this approach was significantly different from what was practiced in the past. This approach was however, personal centric and largely revolved around the personality of Thompson and as such the methodological insight from other quarters was not seriously taken into consideration. Besides the model adapted by Thompson was good for managing a limited number of EBOs and rather was significantly inefficient in managing large number of EBOs. It was because of this reason that a shift towards corporate strategy was made. With the retirement of Thompson, the corporate strategy group formally took over the development of EBOs and as such process was more formalized under the corporate strategy. The staffing was rationalized to add new expertise for project management; marketing and experts from other disciplined were introduced. Further, the processes and systems were more organized and refined besides adding some new elements of managing the EBOs. This therefore allowed IBM to develop competencies which were not traditionally its stronger points thus by focusing on corporate strategy approach, IBM achieved its strategic objectives. Q#4 The current EBO system was more mature and robust in nature as the changes made over the period of time reflected a lot of hard work and strategic insight behind the process. The current EBO system not only reflected broader spectrum of activities but it also included elements which were traditionally not recognized at IBM as the value drivers for the future growth and sustainability. Resource allocation is more efficient and productive in nature as well as the allocation and rationalization of funds became more easier in nature. As against the past practices, the analysis of the new projects was more qualitative in nature as against the quantitative analysis which was the hallmark of IBM in the past. Further, the existing system of EBOs also allows the development of succession planning as well as leadership from within the organization. By developing a system of accountability and responsibility into the new EBO system, the system provided strategic maturity and more formality to the development of emerging businesses at IBM. Q#5 The new system at IBM was firmly in place and presented new opportunities for future growth. However, there were still some problems and ambiguities associated with the process as despite such rigorous process the transition from H2 to H3 was relatively more difficult as IBM was mostly stuck at H2 phase. The development of H2 businesses was not up to the entire satisfaction of the IBM because it did not place a lot of attention on the development of such businesses. As discussed in the case, IBM failed to put in place and adequate and proper managerial approach in place to oversee such businesses. Too much focus was placed on conceiving H3 businesses because they provided better future growth prospects. In order to deal with the businesses reaching the H2 horizon, it is therefore really important that a more customized and tailored focus shall be applied to such businesses. The development of new approaches as well as focused managerial approach shall be one of the cornerstones for dealing with H2 business and as such Herreld must develop strategies which effectively integrate these businesses into the mainstream organizational activities. Since H2 businesses are more predictable as well as easier to manage, it becomes therefore really critical that the top management of IBM shall develop ownership for such businesses and promote those who actually materialized the idea into reality. In order to develop new EBOs it is also important that Herreld must take a broader and more proactive approach based on diversification as one of the strategies to pursue future growth opportunities. One approach which IBM planned to adapt was the strengthening of the corporate strategy staff which can then subsequently refine the ideas and materialize them into reality however, it would be better if the development of new EBOs takes place through multiple sources at IBM rather than solely relying on corporate strategy group. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“IBM casestudy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555523-ibm-casestudy
(IBM Casestudy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555523-ibm-casestudy.
“IBM Casestudy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555523-ibm-casestudy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why Do Large Companies Like IBM Find It Difficult to Create New Businesses

The Marketing Situation of X Infotech

For smaller businesses, which do not have a brand equity advantage, top quality service is the only USP which can give them an edge over the competition.... Naturally, most customers of the firm are company representatives or startup businesses.... Installing a new server costs around $100,000, with storage solutions costing extra.... The company needn't bother about Age and psychographic information about its customers, as most of them are young geeks looking for a foothold entry into new business models....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Trends and issues in the development of information technology for EBusiness

ccording to Australian Bureau of Statistics, 83% of businesses used computers, 71% of businesses use Internet access, and 23% of businesses had web sites in June 2003.... Proportion of businesses placing or receiving orders via the Internet or web was 25% in purchasing and 6% in selling in 2001-2002 and 28% in purchasing and 13% in selling in 2002-2003.... n this work Web services architecture is described that can be adopted as a new service delivery model that incorporates implementation of user and functionality requirements, business processes, design patterns and existing technologies use defining an accomplished B2B e-commerce process solution....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

Its Business, Nothing Personal

This paper "It's Business, Nothing Personal" discusses the claim that certain businesses cooperated with Hitler's war machine that would still have severe repercussions for any company even though more than 60 years have passed since the end of World War II.... Needless to say businesses approved of these ideas and worked hand in hand with the Nazis to improve the economy as Hitler saw fit.... Despite all of these measures, little industry was nationalized and the majority of businesses remained with private owners....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Business argument and ethics

Proponents of a laissez faire approach where businesses succeed or fail depending on.... Those who advocate that government's role is to intervene because markets fail, find single companies or groups of companies controlled by the same Historically in the United States, government has been wary of large corporations who appear to accumulate monopolistic powers where they control both the supply of a particular commodity as well as its price.... In some instances, government has gone so far as to order these huge corporations to be spilt into smaller companies....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Cross Cultural Alliances

Diversification in this case means dealing with different types of customers and businesses and thus covering different parts of the world.... Through joint venturing, small businesses can come together and raise the required capital, and later enjoy the enormous profits made.... joint venture can be defined as a business involving parties who agree to come up with a new entity with new assets by maki contributing to quit.... BM, International Business Machines Corporation, is a multinational technology and consulting company owned by America and headquartered in Armonk in new York....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Contemporary opportunities and problems that confront IBM Company

The company has however undergone a number of organizational changes since its inception and some of these changes have resulted in new challenges while others have been affected in order to keep pace with the changes in the industry.... This paper critically analyzes the contemporary opportunities and problems that confront ibm Company as well as the potential solutions to some of these challenges.... ibm is an American based multinational cooperation that manufactures computer hardware, software....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Foundation of a Successful Retailer in the Difficult Business Environment

In service marketing, businesses need to create strategic marketing practices which provide positive viewpoints of the service as well as getting the service to the right market environment.... Today's companies which provide services must consider issues of how best to position a product to ensure higher sales volumes and increased consumer patronage.... With this idea in mind, companies in the upscale, youth retail sector must consider the four Ps of marketing (product, place, promotion and pricing) as well as the people and processes to deliver a quality service....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Creative Leadership

As if this is not enough, information within the system tends to be difficult to decipher; could be incomplete and highly ambiguous.... Ambiguity is also seen as another challenge that ought to be considered by most leaders since a number of them barely have clarity on what certain events imply, and the overall effect that those events can have on their businesses (Petrie, 2014).... Studies have shown that the new environment is now highly volatile since change occurs on a large scale and quite fast....
20 Pages (5000 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us