StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Ethics of Transplant Allocation Name () Institution () The Ethics of Transplant Allocation Introduction Organ transplant is one of the revolutionary medical advancement that have changed healthcare. Patients with failed organs, including the heart and the kidney can get organ transplants and live normal lives…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper"

Download file to see previous pages

These factors always yield ethical issues that question the ethical nature of the allocation method (Reiser, 2006). For instance, people are allocated organs just because they are wealthy and can pay for them. A medically needy person living far away from the donor may fail to receive the organ, which is given to a less needy person near the donor. Such ethical concerns clearly posit that there lacks an ethical approach for allocating transplant as some people are unfairly treated during the allocation process.

In this regard, this paper evaluates the transplant allocation process using the four major ethical principles, including the principle of non- maleficence, justice, autonomy and beneficence. This determines the possibility of a more ethical way to allocate transplants. Autonomy The autonomy principle is highly employed in the healthcare sector. However, when it comes to determining the criteria for the transplant allocation process, it has minimal use. In fact, Reiser (2006) highlights that to be fair and effective, the allocation process should not be guided by the autonomy principle.

Autonomy means deliberate self-determination or self-rule. The autonomy principle allows a person to make the decisions that one perceives to be morally right without third party interference. Although it is the basis of individual moral values, the principle cannot be employed in the allocation process. This is because in some cases, those allocating transplants may develop sympathy-driven emotional bonds with transplant recipients, such as those who have waited for long and the very young persons, including babies.

If the principle of autonomy is applied by those allocating the organs, they are likely to act based on emotional pressure. Essentially, the allocators are more likely to allocate organs based on emotional bonds development rather than on any specific criteria or fairness. Hence, fairness or justice overrules autonomy in the allocation process to limit ethical issues in the allocation process. Beneficence Beneficence directs that the allocators do not harm, promote the recipients welfare and do good.

Nevertheless, how is this possible in allocating transplants, which are scarce resource?. Ideally, as Jensen (2011) indicates, it is difficult to avoid doing harm, doing good and promoting the welfare of the recipients when allocating transplants. Notably, allocating a kidney to a child based on age or other factors over an older woman who has stayed long in the waiting list or any other factor involves doing good to one patient and harming the other. It may be argued that focusing on the medically needy is doing good, avoiding harm and promoting the welfare of the recipients.

However, other factors, such as the probability of success and being on the waiting list for too long still show that the allocation process may not avoid doing harm or promote recipients welfare. Ideally, it may become evident that a needy person with low or almost zero success chances has been allocated a transplant over a less needy person who with high success rates. In this case, when the transplant fails, it will do no good. In fact, it may cause harm because the ‘less needy’ person may suffer unnecessarily because the transplant could have been successful on him or her.

Categorically, although it is crucial to uphold the principle of beneficence in healthcare, it cannot help formulate an allocation process

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/nursing/1488870-ethical-healthcare-issues-paper
(Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/nursing/1488870-ethical-healthcare-issues-paper.
“Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1488870-ethical-healthcare-issues-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Healthcare Issues Paper

Health Care: Right or Privilege

This paper discusses the ethical problems faced by the lack of better health care and how the different classical theories can be used to finish the problem.... Many national constitutions today recognize that every individual has the right for a better health, and require the state to cater for healthcare services....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

SLP 5 - Healthcare Legal and Ethical Problems and Remedial Action Plans

This paper therefore, seeks to provide remedial action plans, meant to cope with the weaknesses in the legal and ethics section of the California Hospital Medical Center.... Healthcare Legal and Ethical Problems and Remedial Action Plans Name Institution Date Remedial action plan for the Legal and ethical weakness issues being faced by the California Hospital Medical center needs to be put in place.... Legal and ethical issues can be defined as approaches to regulating practices via accepted and developed set of rules....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Corporate Governance and Ethical Responsibility: An Analysis

DoRight; presented to this student as a means of providing the framework behind writing this response paper.... Although a vested interest does not necessarily correlate to an unethical action, it should nonetheless be noted by the reader that this vested interest is every bit as strong as any of those which will be or have been listed within this paper.... These of course obviously include doctors and nurses as well as the full array of primary healthcare providers....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Access to Healthcare as an Ethical Issue

The objective of this research paper is to offer an opportunity to critically think about US health care as a business faced with challenging ethical issues.... This paper summarizes, and explains the ethical issue of access to health care.... hellip; Access to Healthcare as an Ethical Issue The final segment of this paper summarizes two examples of how poor access to healthcare can be resolved.... One of the issues of ethical or moral concern in the U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Health care Capstone

This paper thus explores the implications of ethical issues to healthcare managers in regard to the Identification of the primary stakeholders in ethics management processes, regulatory and ethical issues which may occur, and strategies by which managers may resolve professional, organizational, and personal ethical issues identified.... Generally, for healthcare managers, ethical issues pertain to the right course of action to take in circumstances that are unclear or in situations where there seems to be a disagreement on the most appropriate thing to do....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Administrative Ethical Issues in Healthcare

As such, it is required that healthcare professionals keep patients' information secret and private unless there is a consent to disclose health information.... Department of Health & Human Services (HHS.... ov) and titled, “Stolen Laptops Lead to Important HIPAA Settlements.... ?? The case reports an April 2014 incidence where two organizations paid the HHS office for… In effect, the enforcement steps accentuate the potential risk to the security of private information in the unencrypted laptops that were Put simply, two organizations are forced to pay OCR a sum of $1,975,220 for losing two laptops that have patients' private information (HHS, 2014)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Patients Autonomy in Deciding What to Do at the End-of-Life

This paper focuses on the issues of bioethical and legal issues and challenges of health administrators, who care for elderly or terminally ill patients.... Thus, like the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ, 2003) analysis state that awareness needs to be brought forward in advance care planning is critical in resolving some legal and ethical issues revolving around the end of life care, especially patient self-determination or autonomy with decision-making issues....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Ethics in Public Administration

The aim of this paper is to identify the ethical implications and the fulfillment of social justice as far as the purpose of the US healthcare is concerned.... For many developed countries, the public financing model of healthcare has worked tremendously well as it enables the provision of the same level of health care for the masses.... This system makes it mandatory for every member of the population to pay the health tax in order to be eligible to benefit from free or minimal cost healthcare services....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us