StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Affirmative Action (a reflection on a moral problem) – PHI 1700 13 December 2013 Introduction Affirmative action came out of the efforts by proponents and advocates in the Civil Rights Movement to ensure what they had fought for will find concrete manifestation in real acts to end discrimination…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action)"

Download file to see previous pages

Other countries similarly enlightened adopted the same principles of this affirmative action law but termed it differently, such as “positive discrimination” in the United Kingdom in which discrimination was given a positive and beneficial connotation or in Canada where it is called as employment equity to mean everybody has equal chances at getting employed if a person has the same qualities, qualifications, credentials, and capabilities as another person. In all these countries, the main idea was to take positive action that will equalize everybody.

In reference to the Women's Liberation Movement (or feminism for short), the same laws in principle were adopted and likewise applied to women to have the same opportunities as men. Some countries adopted a different system altogether such as using quotas to allocate a certain number of slots to members of some minority groups. The same idea of affirmative action was soon introduced to schools and universities in admitting students for enrollment. In this paper, it will be argued how procedural affirmative action is the better of the two variants. . The only remaining criterion for a job applicant is his or her qualifications for the position.

In a sense, this first side of affirmative action is negatively stated, that to achieve the noble aims of affirmative action, any employer should ignore the applicant's race, creed, or color. This first side is what is now called as the procedural affirmative action (Cahn 14). On the other hand, the second side is now more nuanced as it carefully takes into its consideration the very things which were supposed to be ignored or not considered such as an applicant's race, creed, or color; the elements which will make affirmative action a success is to embrace the same criteria which were to be ignored or discarded as mentioned earlier.

It is now incumbent upon a potential employer to carefully take into consideration the same things like race, creed, or color when evaluating an applicant. This is what is required now by the so-called preferential affirmative action by paying very close attention to the same criteria. These two seemingly contradictory aspects of the affirmative action program can be problematic for those desirous to comply with its provisions and objectives although both two aims aspire for the same result of equality in opportunities.

The main problem is whether to use the same set of criteria and then whether to grant compensatory advantages to group members of minorities who were discriminated against. This flies in the face of the ideals of affirmative action which is to allow everybody to compete fairly on an equal footing against everybody else. This implies preference for diversity to enrich everybody's experience but the philosophical debate on this issue has

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action) Essay”, n.d.)
Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1497260-reflecting-on-a-moral-problem-affirmative-action
(Reflecting on a Moral Problem ( Affirmative Action) Essay)
Reflecting on a Moral Problem ( Affirmative Action) Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1497260-reflecting-on-a-moral-problem-affirmative-action.
“Reflecting on a Moral Problem ( Affirmative Action) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1497260-reflecting-on-a-moral-problem-affirmative-action.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reflecting on a moral problem ( affirmative action)

Ethical decisions in leadership

The issue to be addressed here is to decide who is to be selected when there are three equally important candidates and out of them, two are minority women who deserve affirmative action In the given case, Karen Hathaway is confused as to who is to be selected for promotion from three potential candidates.... The issue to be addressed here is to decide who is to be selected when there are three equally important candidates and out of them, two are minority women who deserve affirmative action (Garrett, 2009)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Multicultural Counselling Practice

However, the moment that the counsellor starts seeing his/her values and perspectives as superior over that of the client, the problem begins.... The paper "Multicultural Counselling Practice" examines two scenarios: the woman, who is experiencing some of the identified types of gender microaggression and these are sexist languages and assumption of traditional gender roles and the minister struggling to come to terms with his own homosexuality....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Gilbane Gold Ethical Model

This problem on fairness has been raised by individuals and masses for affirmative action on in convincing ethics.... Although some may conceptualize that women's ethics will continue for a while despite taking of affirmative action, some have a different belief that there can be... The plant's engineer dismisses a consultant, believing the action was out of warnings on discharge levels.... The only action he arrives at is blowing the whole crime out through the media....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Reflective Paper

Reflective Paper Introduction Human Resource Mangement (HRM) is all about managing the people working in an organization or group of people who are employed by any firm, company or business that produces goods or services.... The aim of HRM is to : Make an organization successful Help the employees enjoy their work Help the employees do their best To ensure the safety of the employees while they are working To make sure that employees receive suitable compensation for their work....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Positive Action

This case study discusses the positive or affirmative action in business, that refers to any measures and initiatives that are specifically designed to mitigate or counteract the effects of past acts of discrimination and also to eliminate stereotyping during the work hours.... Adopting a recruitment policy that is based on affirmative action while driven by good motives can pose a great challenge to the human resource function.... One way of making a difference in this issue is through providing positive action initiatives at the workplace, that are not legally obligatory in the United Kingdom....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Management Is Doing Things Right

Complementary to this is the transparency of decisions and actions, as well as demonstrating accountability for decision and action outcomes.... "Management Is Doing Things Right" paper presents definitions of leadership, as defined by the author, five of his/her friends, and a selection of peer-reviewed articles from the author's class reading list....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

A Review of Definitions of Leadership

Overall, this review highlights the importance for a leader to be flexible to the situation and context in which they find themselves making decisions and taking action.... Complementary to this is transparency of decision and actions, as well as demonstrating accountability for decision and action outcomes....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Morals Based Principles

That means being an Aristotelian, the question one should ask is whether the action leads to personal happiness.... If there is an answer in affirmation, the action is virtuous.... However, a look into the various moral theories proves that none of them is strongly against killing.... According to the very basis of 'categorical imperative', one should only pursue such actions which can be made universal laws (Kant: the moral order, n....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us