StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

VIII of Plato's Republic - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This book review "Book VIII of Plato's Republic" presents Plato’s Republic where Socrates describes four models of city rule. Each stage is considered worse than the one before and Socrates argues that, since the city will be ruled by man, each of these stages will eventually be passed through…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Book VIII of Platos Republic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "VIII of Plato's Republic"

There will therefore be a division between these two groups and from this division will come the compromise solution of a timocracy. The property in the city will be distributed among the powerful and people who worked the land will become beholden to the landowners. This ruling class will have to defend their position and so will wage war constantly. They will focus their energy on training for war and being physically fit. They will therefore require a leader who is disposed to war and this, argues Socrates, is a man ruled by spirit, the product of an aristocratic father who teaches him rationality and a mother who teaches him a love of money.

            This timocracy will then degenerate into an oligarchy. The love of money of the ruler will spread to the entire ruling class and money will then become the key prerequisite for becoming a member of the ruling class, argues Socrates. Due to this false pursuit of money, society will have increasing problems as it is increasingly divided into rich and poor. Further, such a society creates drones, people who don’t belong to any class in the city, such as beggars and thieves.

This type of city is ruled by a man who seeks wealth and desires to keep it for himself. This is his only goal. The oligarchy will then be replaced by a democracy. This happens as a result of the practice of money lending. By now there is a small group of the rich elite and a vast number of poor people. The poor eventually revolt and set up a society based on freedom with the ruling class chosen at random due to the basic philosophy of equality. However, there is no order or harmony because the people who rule are not necessarily suitable for the job.

While the oligarchy is ruled by a man with necessary desires (desires which reflect a real human need) the democracy is ruled by a man with unnecessary desires (desires which are superfluous such as a desire for excessive wealth). The city then descends into tyranny. The drones in this society play on the fears of rich and poor and encourage a revolt. When the poor overpower the rich the lead drone becomes ruler, killing all those who oppose him. All of society becomes enslaved to him, while the other drones become his bodyguards.

            Book IX describes what the man who rules the tyranny is like. He loses his sense of moderation because he is affected by the drones and moves towards lawlessness and a lack of control. He has no idea of when to stop and spends all his money on feasts, women, and extravagant living. He borrows money and then when this resource is exhausted he loots temples to get the money he needs to fulfill his uncontrollable desires. Finally, he resorts to murder to get money.

He is driven by erotic love and performs the nightmarish acts when awake that his predecessors performed only in their dreams. He ends up in abject poverty and lives in continual fear of revenge for the terrible acts he has committed. He is therefore the most wretched of men because his life is not just.    

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Book VIII of Platos Republic Example | Topics and Free Essays, n.d.)
Book VIII of Platos Republic Example | Topics and Free Essays. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1894587-plato-rebuplic
(Book VIII of Platos Republic Example | Topics and Free Essays)
Book VIII of Platos Republic Example | Topics and Free Essays. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1894587-plato-rebuplic.
“Book VIII of Platos Republic Example | Topics and Free Essays”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1894587-plato-rebuplic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Book VIII of Plato's Republic

Book review

Jerry Ciacho November 3, 2012 Krakatoa: The Day the World Exploded British writer, journalist, explorer and geologist Simon Winchester delves into and explores the lasting and the ever so powerful consequences and results of the disastrous and shattering explosion in the coast of Indonesia of the planet's most devastating super volcano island, Krakatoa....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Allegory of The Cave by Plato

The 'Allegory of The Cave' is an allegory used by Plato in 'The republic'.... The allegory is told and then interpreted by the character Socrates.... Socrates is talking to Glaucon and narrating a fable to illustrate what it is like to be a philosopher- a lover of wisdom.... hellip; It is related to the metaphor of the sun and the analogy of the divided line....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Ideal society in the Republic of Plato

For example, it is easy for any reader of plato's republic to say “What a life without a wife and without one's own identifiable progeny” anent his ideas of communism of wives and children.... hellip; The article defines utmost strength on knowledge and virtue as the most significant in plato's republic.... plato's republic is, indeed, a masterly work of philosophy.... The paper “Ideal society in the republic of Plato” operates mainly on research question which can be stated as follows: How does Plato construct his ideal society in The republic: Concerning Justice?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Synopsis of the Republic

The presents 'Synopsis of the republic' focuses on 'The republic' by Plato which is a unique attempt to configure the political life of people with the idea of a state named 'republic'.... Rather it is conjured up by the fictional characters in the book.... book II continues with the political definition of justice.... The responsibilities of a state are described in details in book III.... In book IV Socrates describes, as the sole target of the State is to ensure the good for its people, the strenuous training of the citizens can be justified....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of Plato's Republic

The author focuses on the book "The republic" by Plato in which he pulls together many of the ideas of his mentor, Socrates, to present his idea of the realities of life.... The reality is not the world of material things that we can see in everyday life but consists of something more abstract....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Platos Perfect World in The Republic

The book review "Plato's Perfect World in The republic" states that in Plato's book The republic, the author presents his idea of a perfect world in which society offers every individual the chance to fully develop his or her own intellect and remain actively engaged with their community.... hellip; The author shows that in book three, he points out the importance of providing each person with the opportunity to expand their mind through intellectual study and the importance of the intellectual study to develop quality leaders who are interested most in guarding and protecting the state that created them....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

The Human Persona and Numerous Emotions in Langston Hughes, Plato and John Stenbecks Poems

This book review discusses Langston Hughes' English of Theme B fashions the major theme in his poems about origins and its implication to the persona as a writer.... This review discusses themes in poems that range from the expounding of origins to education, to love and to life and death, among others, puts into perspective a flow of human emotions....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Plato, Republic, from Book X

In book X of The republic, Socrates turns to the question regarding poetry and poses arguments convincingly concerning why they are perceived as dangerous for the city.... hellip; Secondly, the images that these poets betray are often the worst form of soul, thereby neglecting the virtuous part of the soul; which evidently diverts the energy from s In book X of The republic, Socrates turns to the question regarding poetry and poses arguments convincingly concerning why they are perceived as dangerous for the city....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us