StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
VIEWS Conservative and Liberal Views on Welfare Dilemma Introduction In recent years the US has seen an increasing polarization of income levels with the top 1% rising at a far greater rate than the remaining 99%.(Saez 2008) This has spawned protest movements which have the potential to threaten social stability…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma"

Download file to see previous pages

The unemployable category includes primarily single mothers with young children or those considered to physically and/or mentally unfit for employment. The welfare dilemma is that while people expect governments to provide a safety net for those unable to fend for themselves, it has become increasingly difficult for them to discharge this obligation due to rising costs which must be financed by increasing taxes and government borrowing or a combination of both(Voregeli 2011). In simplest terms the liberal solution is the increased taxes/borrowing model while the conservatives favor freezing if not reducing benefits in the interest of keeping both taxation levels and government spending in check Most Accurate and Unbiased View Conservatives argue that generous welfare benefits encourage dependency and laziness at least among those deemed employable.

While that is undoubtedly true in a relatively few cases, benefits are rarely sufficient to provide an attractive alternative to gainful employment. Beyond that, I would argue that people have a psychological need to be productive in some way. The liberal view is that welfare is rarely a preferred option either from a financial or self satisfaction viewpoint. People obtain welfare usually because they feel trapped and see no other option. I would therefore argue that the liberal view of welfare recipients as mostly forced into this role because of uncontrollable circumstances is a more accurate and unbiased view than the conservative one of them being lazy freeloaders intent on milking the system.

It must be remembered, in a society with still a strong work ethic welfare recipients have a very low status. The Best Government Policy Even when conservatives admit there are people in genuine need, they often argue this can be met by churches and charities. I think the need is too great for this to be a realistic option. They do however have a point about the escalating costs of government programs. To deal with this I would recommend some increase in taxation especially on the wealthy. While low taxes do stimulate growth to some extent, there comes a point where even lower taxes are not effective.

For example, the Bush tax cuts were based on the assumption that the wealthy would spend more of their increased net income on new businesses, employing more workers who foster other businesses with their increased income in a “trickle down spin off” effect. This did not happen as many of the elite simply “sat on” their increased wealth. Therefore, I would argue that the Republican philosophy of small government and lower taxes stimulating economic growth has only limited validity. On the other hand, while I advocate proactive government welfare policies, I think savings could be made if there was more attention paid to return citizens to productive lives as soon as possible, even for categories currently considered unemployable such as single mothers and physically disabled people.

For example, with the expansion of information technology it might be worthwhile for the government to provide them with training and home computers so that they could eventually work as data processors. Dr. Tim has advocated that those on welfare able to work be given a choice of being cut off welfare or agreeing to do necessary unskilled work within or without the civil service.( Tim 2012) If they worked for a company, the government

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1448725-conservative-and-liberal-views-on-the-welfare
(Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1448725-conservative-and-liberal-views-on-the-welfare.
“Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1448725-conservative-and-liberal-views-on-the-welfare.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Conservative and Liberal Views on the Welfare Dilemma

A Summary and Analysis of Peter Katel's Child Poverty

However, as welfare programs and monetary allocation seem insufficient in alleviating the condition of children, questions on whether increasing the budget to address poverty-related concerns arise.... A Summary and Analysis of Peter Katel's Child Poverty: Are Out-of-Wedlock Births the Root Cause?...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Republican vs democrat

Democrats versus Republicans conservative and liberal perspective, on a number of points, may agree and vary with respect to their own ideologies.... As liberals, they believe that the government has a great role to ensure welfare of individuals.... So as the proponent of the “Inconvenient Truth” his claim about the global warming issue and industrialization triggers a remarkable impact on the stand of conservative individuals who are trying to maximize individual gain rather than long-term sustainability....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

AN EXAMINATION OF THE EXTENT TO WHICH IMMIGRATION AND ETHNIC RELIGIOUS PLURALISM THREATENS THE WELFARE

hellip; Heterogeneity and multiculturalism have, according to Banting and Kymlicka (2006), been interpreted by some as an immediate threat to welfare citizenship and the welfare state, both of which derive from the presumption of shared identity.... To offset the potential problematic of fragmented identities and its implications for the continuation and sustenance of the welfare state, nation-states have engaged in the accommodation of plurality through multicultural policies which are intended, according to Banting and Kymlicka (2006), if not to preserve the welfare state, ensure the continued unity and unification of the nation-state. As briefly indicated in the above, ethnic and religious plurality constitute a potential threat to the very notion of the welfare state and its associate welfare citizenship....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

How liberal ought a state to be

liberal ideas are of particular importance, as since its emergence as a coherent ideology and until our time liberalism, in one form or another, is actively involved into the mentioned discussions about the present and future of democracy and freedom in this and other countries.... In its classical meaning, the word "liberal" relates to a political philosophy based on the world view of the Enlightenment, which attempts to limit the political power and to defend the case of individual rights....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Political Ideologies in the US

liberal legislative leadership, partly through necessity, has instigated steady governmental growth well beyond where the architects of the constitution and most citizens would favor.... and will explain the discrepancies of a failed conservative ideology, which has been a major factor in this awakening.... The conservative ideology is based upon their interpretation of Christian-based morality.... Those of a conservative ideology are against legalizing abortion....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Issues of Left-Wing or Right-Wing Politics

Left-wing ideology, which arose to counter the right-wing dominance, was based on reason, and the liberal philosophers pointed out at the lack of natural reason for the existence of relations centred around any form of dominance and concluded that all human beings have the same moral worth and thus should have equal rights and all religious practices should be equally treated by law.... According to Giddens (2001), 'left' refers to radical or progressive political groups while the term 'right' is used to imply more conservative groups....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Political Ideologies of the US

liberal legislative leadership, partly through necessity, has instigated steady governmental growth well beyond where the architects of the constitution and most citizens would favor.... and will explain the discrepancies of a failed conservative ideology, which has been a major factor in this awakening.... The conservative ideology is based upon their interpretation of Christian-based morality.... Those of a conservative ideology are against legalizing abortion....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Public Administration and Analytical Observations on the Works of Theodore Lowi, Hayeks Legal Theory

From the paper "Public Administration and Analytical Observations on the Works of Theodore Lowi, Hayek's Legal Theory " it is clear that Lowi has been right that populist conservatism is a threat to liberal rights as it only recognizes the authority of God, scripture, tradition and community norms.... Professing that the ideologies of dominant political coalitions contain the seeds of their own destruction, Lowi suggests that the efforts of a new conservative Right to enforce a national, religion-based morality have brought about the demise of the Republican era....
33 Pages (8250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us